Michaleno's Pizzeria 234 East Dekora Street, Saukville, WI 53080

"I asked if they would do 1/2-1/2 on a large specialty pizza. They said yes they do. So I ordered 1/2 veggie specialty and 1/2 philly steak specialty. They charged me $6 extra saying theres extra toppings. To my knowledge all places charge the full price of the expensive 1/2 and nothing extra. If i said I want a whole veggie pizza, add steak on half the pizza, thatd still be $2 extra (price to add on a whole large) with the price of veggie which was the cheaper one in my case. Just didnot understand this logic when you are doing 1/2 and 1/2. The Veggie pizza was amazing. Nicely done. The steak smelled a little bit like its been in the freezer for a while but still edible. The fish fry I ordered was no where up to standards. Same smell of the thing sitting in freezer for a while. Onion rings were burnt and I wish I didnt pay extra to get those burnt onion rings instead of fries. Not a very pleasant first experience I'd say."

"The first time I tried Michelano’s Pizzeria in Saukville was shortly after they opened. I thought that the pizza was good but nothing special. However, the second time I ordered their 16” Deluxe pizza, I was hooked! It was loaded with toppings, the thin crust was excellent and the premium mozzarella cheese was gooey, and not burned, like at a lot of other pizza places. Since then, I’ve probably had five or six other pizzas and I’ve never been disappointed. I weighed my last 16” Deluxe pizza on my kitchen scale and it weighed a full 30 ounces, most of which consisted of cheese and six meat and vegetable toppings. The pizza cost was $22.50 and it was well worth it. If you have any leftovers, scrape off the cheese and other toppings, and make a pizza omelet! Fast, simple, delicious and nutritious. And when they say “20 minutes” they mean 20 minutes. I’ve yet to have had to wait for my order. They’ve always been fast and efficient. Once you’re hooked like I am, you’ll want to get Michelano’s punch card - buy 10, get one free!"

"Owner's dad is friendly, owner was too busy working the kitchen to talk. Great Pizza! Great service! They take pride in their food! Atmosphere scored a 3 because the saukville location is carryout or delivery only, so atmosphere is not. Everything was clean and orderly!"

"Gross! The picture is not fries...their wings. The calzone sauce tastes like expired burnt basil. I had to spit it out. The spicey wings are bland and very dry. Tried the 4 appetizer. Mozzerella sticks are not great, the fried mushrooms are very wet and uncrunchy, the spinach artichoke was okay and the fish bites were good. Raspberry cheesecake were good. Never again though."

"This was our first time trying this place for pizza and we were not impressed. We order the specialty chicken Sicilian as seen below, we were quit confused when we opened the box the see what appear to be canned green beans… which they were not of course but I was taught to eat with my eyes and this through me off a bit. We added onions to this same pizza and at first glance you can’t distinguish onion from chicken chunk, same bland white color and taste. This pizza was surprisingly okay, my first impression of the it set me back but the flavor was okay the garlic Parmesan was good chicken was bland and as my wife said “ it looks like they just through the onions on, they didn’t even give them time to cook.” Not my number one choice. Pizza 2 cheese pepperoni and sausage, nothing fancy, was also okay. Sauce was good I liked how it wasn’t too sweet. Crust was a good mixture of crisp bottom with a pillowy edge crust. To me there was nothing that stood out or spoke to me about these pizzas, think it’s good for a late dinner when you get back from up north and the kids are hangry on a Sunday night."