Main Street Pizza 106 Main Street, Star Prairie, WI 54026

"Pizza is delicious!!!! Wish they had real garlic “bread” instead of garlic pizza fries. Too much sauce on the Parmesan bites! Such friendly staff and great service!!!"

"I really wanted to like this place because it's one of the few places that deliver to my house but I think I will have to go elsewhere and just do pick up. When the owner is working the pizza is great and the service matches. When the teenagers are working the pizza is wrong or cooked incorrectly and they won't do anything to correct it. Tonight was my final straw. My husband ordered a pepperoni, mushroom, and black olive pizza and was told 45 minutes to an hour for delivery at 6:40. After an hour he called just to check in and was told that it had just left so he waited 20 min and called back only to be told that it was just put in the oven. When he asked if a discount or credit could be applied the person on the phone told him no, he messed up on the delivery time, "my bad." So to shorten it up we finally received our soggy lukewarm pizza at 9pm. It is really a shame because when it's good, it tastes amazing."

"Great tasting pizza, young impatient staff. We stopped in for a pizza after winning our baseball game & had a really bad dining experience. We could tell they were annoyed that we came so close to closing time. We said we'd eat outside. We asked for a pitcher of water along with our pops, but she said they didn't have pitchers for water, so we went out to the car and got our water bottles to refill in the bathroom sink. They brought our pizza out to the table in a box & gave us paper plates. No napkins, parm, or red pepper shakers. Had to ask for napkins. I went back in to get plastic forks & knives. She said they didn't have any, only offered plastic spoons. My man then went in to ask for silverware, to which the girl also claimed they didn't have. It was getting ridiculous. He asked if the owner would tell him they didn't offer anything to eat with & she shook her head yes. He asked her name, and she wouldn't give it to him. A young guy hanging out in the corner waiting for girls to get off work piped up, saying, "They're trying to close, man." The girl finally produced some forks to eat our sloppy pizza with. As we were outside eating, they shut down the restaurant, locked the doors & left us sitting out on the patio, telling us there's a garbage on the sidewalk and to clean up ourselves. Clearly, there is a lack of training/supervision with kids running the place. I've never had a restaurant staff leave before we did. Very bizarre. I highly recommend skipping the dine in experience!"

"I ordered a taco pizza and it was absolutely delicious! They were a bit busy but very nice and polite 100% worth the wait!"

"Solid choice for hand tossed pizza. I will definitely try well done on my pizza next time. Crust was crunchy but the bottom could have used a bit more time. I did have a bunch of sauce and toppings on my pizzas so that could have been a factor. Would pizza again. Worth a try. 5 stars."