Pago's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine 6446 Arizona 179, Sedona, AZ 86351

"We were about 45 minutes early to check-in our hotel but we were hungry, so the front desk recommended Pago's. It was 2:15 on a Saturday and we were the only people in there, but our late lunch was really good. We both had the 1/2 Italian sandwich with the bowl of minestrone(me), salad (hubs). My soup was FULL of chunk veggies (carrots, broccoli, cauliflower) & good & hot, with just enough broth. And those Italian sandwiches? SO good! We both had ours hot & they were so yummy. Even though it was half a sandwich and soup/salad, we were stuffed from the large portions. The hostess/server was friendly, chatted with us a bit, was attentive... we'll define back to try a pizza, too!"

"Looking for worst service ever? Come here! Waitress didn't look up, told us "sit where you want". Literally slid the menus onto the table, again no eye contact and walked off. We laughed and walked off (kindly returning the menus, we're not thugs) and she didn't even seem surprised we left! It's taken me more time to write this than the time we were there. I scored the food as I had to, but unsure what they tasted like."

"We spent a week in Sedona, and tried our best to save money where we could, which is not an easy thing to do in Sedona. That means pizza and burgers. The pizza we got from here stood out from everything else when we asked our boys their favorite meal. We appreciate the quality, and bang-for-your-buck. We took our meals back to our hotel, and this was a great surprise. Our 2 boys usually smash a pizza by themselves, and the four of us couldn’t even finish one pizza. Kudos, and next time we are in town, we will be back."

"It was delicious and they were kind enough to squeeze us in without a reservation. The creamy feta salad dressing was delicious and unique! The pizza crust was wonderful... Thick and delightful with a nice light crisp edge."

"It got packed after we got seated so service was on the slower side. Our salad had hair in it and it took a while until we got a new one. Calamari was okay, chicken dishes were all dry, and the pastas were salty. There’s already tip included at 18% for bigger parties and the dishes are all on the expensive side. Not the biggest fan, but portions were big."