El Maguey

"I must’ve gotten the wrong restaurant bc I ordered Arroz Con Pollo, an hour before close, and they charged me more than any other place I’ve been for some OVERLY drenched chicken & hard flavorless rice, No veggies, No Mexican Salad, Hoursssss old chips and a tomato paste aka salsa. Dude clearly didn’t wanna argue bc he shut my ?’s down quick. I’ll stick with the el maguey in lake STL or Taco Bell even.. Wish I took photos before I threw $20 in the trash."

"The service here was great and our server was very on top of things. The salsa, however tasted more like tomatoes than anything and the food was not good. We ordered the lunch enchilada and lunch Quesadilla. They both tasted cheap and unseasoned, including the rice and the chicken was dry. We will not be returning."

"100% the most unauthentic Mexican food I've ever been had. To each their own I guess. Upside is friendly staff."

"The service is always great and the food is always delicious. We have had only positive experiences at this location and the food comes amazingly fast after ordering. The mixed Fajitas and the Taco Salad Fajitas are our favorite dishes. The margaritas are also wonderful!"

"If you’re looking for a lovely experience customer service experience and quality Taco Tuesday supper…this is NOT your place. KEEP heading down the other way. I ordered to go tacos (since I am 3 mins away). I knew it would be fresh as I’m so close. Little did I know the order would be taken by a rude employee on the phone taking orders and later to tell me “next time check your order while you’re here”. (You took the order as it’s your voice and you even told me I ordered 3 tacos hard…I’m 100% sure I told you what I wanted, “which was not hard” because I WANTED IT. Do not forget the unseasoned chicken you threw in the hard shell taco. You gave that to the person picking it up and then expect her to drive it back since my car is being worked on!) The employee’s mistake should not be pushed on your customer. It’s your mistake, not mine. My mistake was to pay for food you made incorrectly. The lack of customer service should really be rethought as Mexican restaurants are all over and the weekly holiday meal is “Taco Tuesday”. I want everyone to know this El Maguey in OFallon, MO has ruined the name for them all. I strongly encourage everyone to avoid this place."