Vito & Nick's Pizzeria

"I had high hopes for this place and it's pizza. Since they have been placed on so many best pizza of Chicago lists. After eating the pizza though I don't get it. The pizza is banal with nothing special. It's a basic thin crust pizza that's well done though it is edible and okay it should no way be rated as one of the best of anywhere. I had leftovers that I took home and cooked in my air fryer which made the crust a little crunchier and actually had a better flavor than when it did when it was fresh. I won't go back to this place. It had cobwebs hanging from the ceiling fairly dirty and the service was lacking. Seems like the place is for regulars that haven't gone anywhere else in a long long time. So I will continue my search for the best pizza elsewhere."

"Food… yummy!!! Delicious thin sausage pizza. Delicious crispy breaded mushroom: YUMMY! It was flavored and juicy experience in your mouth."

"This place was recommended by two different people so I decided to give it a try. Ordered a thin crust pepperoni pizza. I have to say I am EXTREMELY disappointed. The cheese is severely lacking and it was overcooked. The flavor is nothing to write home about either. Tastes like cheap frozen pizza; sauce tastes like basic tomato paste and there is too much oregano...very salty as well. At $24 dollars this mediocre pizza is way overpriced. I should have went to Palermos, Lou Malnatis or Pizanos. I will never order from Nick & Vitos ever again."

"Pizza is good, but for my tastes I prefer it hotter and cheesier, more sauce with a crispier crust. I don't think it should be on a top pizza list, but I'd definitely devour the tiny cut square pieces again next time. Packed with locals on a Saturday night. Cash only. Old style beer bar. Carpet on the walls and old pics. Super friendly service."

"Old school thin crust pizza that deserves its great reputation. The pizza was outstanding! Thin and crispy just like we love it! Substantial toppings without overwhelming the crust. VERY old school/no frills place but the food is excellent. Our server (possibly Mary, if I recall) was an absolute joy!"