Cafè Calamari 10 East Geneva Street, Williams Bay, WI 53191

"Very nice here. Great for a high-ish end night out. Food was really tasty. Service was nice. Atmosphere was warm. I personally didn’t care for the tablets they use instead of a traditional menu, but all and all a good experience."

"My wife and I were on vacation in Lake Geneva a few weeks ago on my birthday and she took me here for dinner. The atmosphere was very relaxing, chilled and romantic. To order your food, the waiter presents you with tablets where you can look up everything on the menu. I love it. Makes everything very easy. My wife and I started off the night with a few glasses of wine, beers and a fabulous whiskey stone sour. First, they brought us warm baked bread with parmesan, garlic, and olive oil. Then we ordered appetizers Oysters Rockefeller. Let me tell you they were so amazing like nothing I've ever had before and I've had Oysters Rockefeller in Florida and let me tell you it didn't even hold a candle to the ones they prepared for us at Café Calamari. Phenomenal! For dinner we split the chicken alfredo with broccoli. So very tasty! Highly recommended. And for dessert chocolate tiramisu it was so very good! I rate this classy restaurant five stars⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ definitely check this place out if you're in Lake Geneva, you will not be disappointed! And thank you very much to Brian, the chef Mark our waiter, Marcus, the bartender and Heather the hostess for making our dinner experience at Cafe Calamari most memorable, we will be back!"

"It's the restaurant is located in there one of the best parts of town, right in front of the lake. The food is excellent. I hardly highly recommended chicken piccata in the house salad. This salad was so good we had to order two. The waiter and waitresses in the bus boys were very nice. The service was a little disorganized. We really didn't know who our waiter was. Everything took longer to get to the table. If the service gets fixed is definitely a five star restaurant."

"My sisters and I dined here on August 18, 2023. The atmosphere and our waiter Tony was great. I give this place 5 stars for the waiter only. Our experience with the management team was not pleasant. The image attached shows a plate with a fly on it. The plate was sent back to the kitchen to be replaced, but the same plate of food returned to us with sauce covering the area where my sister ate from. This was unacceptable. We requested to speak with the manager. The manager did not take ownership of what happened. Instead, redirected to make us at fault. I would say she did give us something off our bill. But that isn't the principle. Acknowledgment of fault would have been better. We paid our bill, thanked Tony, our waiter, and decided never to return to this establishment. Sad because it could have gained our repeated business. We hoped for a better experience. Please use caution before taking your first bite."

"Nice dining experience. The first impression from the receptionist was on the unpleasant side but the wonderful waitress,great food and tasty drinks erased that first experience. The place is casual and relaxing but with a slight upscale vibe."