Casey's,

103 6th Avenue East, Andalusia, IL 61232

"Screws up my order yet again... ordered bbq chicken extra bbq sauce extra cheese and no onions. They added banana peppers and either red peppers or tomatoes not sure which one it was, pizza had to be thrown in garbage due to food allergy. Called to complain and was promised NEXT TIME we order pizza will be correct. HIGHLY Disappointed"

"I stop by every single week on Mondays. There is NEVER any hot food. I'm sick of it. No hot food in the cases and multiple employees always standing around."

"Lived in this area for a long time, when the new Casey’s was built it went down hill. Every time I stop there is no food and if there is it’s dried up and nasty. If you don’t go early to get doughnuts for the kids it’s just stuff nobody wants, also drinks are not stocked very well. Usually at least 2 employees standing around talking to each other. I won’t order a pizza from this location."

"I have lived in Andalusia for over 30 years. I have seen many of the same comments regarding the pizza. The original store had great pizza. Then the new store was built and the pizza went downhill fast. At first, I thought it was maybe the new ovens needed to be broken in or poor training of the pizza makers but it still sucks years later. I heard someone say the just other day that they always take their pizza home and finish cooking it themselves. It has never been cooked thoroughly. I, like most people like to have the cheese brown and bubbly and the crust firm but it does not happen. I have been driving 6 – 10 miles into Milan to get pizza. Including the Casey's in Milan! That should not have to be when I live 3 blocks away. Other Casey’s stores are still good and have all heard the complaints and say “we know”. The Andalusia Casey’s just doesn’t get it! Done venting. Please fix it!"

"Had to give kudos a young man who works for you. I am not sure of his name but he was working today 2-1-22. I don't frequent Casey's but have stopped by a few times in the last two months. This young man has been cheery and kind each time. He is a nice change from a lot of overworked employees these days. He is an asset to Casey's and you should consider him for a management position. Better hold onto his great service!"