Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen 2525 Bardstown Road, Louisville, KY 40205

"Revised down to 1 star. Two thanksgiving's in a row with an inedible very undercooked pie. If you like your pastry with a soggy bottom and no colour, then I guess this is for you."

"We love this place! Delicious pie and ice cream!"

"It’s always a pleasure tasting some fresh pie. So many places just order pies in from a factory but I’m almost certain these are made by hand in small batches. If that’s not the case then you could’ve fooled me. The crust was immaculate and the filling tasted bright and not overly sweet. We got the seasonal peach pie and couldn’t have been more impressed. I got a scoop of crème brûlée ice cream which was a mistake because it didn’t taste anything like crème brûlée and plain vanilla ice cream would’ve better accompanied the pie. My girlfriend got the mocha chip and she loved it. The only thing we didn’t like about this place was the incessant sounds of dancing from the studio overhead. I don’t know how the workers can tolerate hearing hours of that every day. More power to them. Overall would recommend."

"Love love love this place!! Quaint little place with homemade pies, ice cream, cookies and cakes and even coffee. Very friendly staff as well! Their chocolate chip and praline ice creams are very yummy!! The chocolate chip cookies are pretty good too. I took home a piece of the mixed berry pie, wish I had taken home the whole pie!! Talk about delicious!! Will definitely visit again when in the area!"

"The name is long and not that catchy. Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen. The floors are scuffed but the booth seats still shine, And the wrought iron chairs are surely the originals. Not many places these days have bells that tingle when you come in the door Its a place you want to walk into with both your grandpa and your daughter. The marvel of ice cream is certainly timeless And as old as the building was, the tables were clean and the pies were fresh. I just have to say, they don't have places like this in Scottsdale. You can take the girl out of Kentucky, but there will always be some Kentucky in this girl. I hope I never am too far removed from brick building and hand-written signs and fresh-baked pie and jukeboxes. And I really, really hope this place stays in business when I have grandkids of my own."