Hometown Pizza - Shelbyville

"Stops her along the side of the road passing through on the Bourbon Trail. Pizza was very good super heavy on the toppings. Reasonable price. Place didn't look open at first so they are. Place has a bar but not much of a bartender as wasn't sure how to make some of the drinks on the menu. Please filled up a little bit more later we stayed. Great variety on the menu."

"I wanted to love it. This was my first time at the newest Shelbyville location so that tells you how long it has been. When it was up in town I used to go after all the county home games. Sad to say it's not as good as I remembered. Everything was just mediocre from the sit down to the food, to the service. Started with the cheesey, bacon fries. I don't recommend. The cheese was hard and stiff and the bacon was gummy. I was really excited about the cauliflower crust offering. My boyfriend and I ordered different pizzas. I have food restrictions. Sadly, the kitchen got my personal pizza order wrong so my boyfriend's pizza sat on the table and was cold when my pizza was finally delivered to the table. The waitress acted like it was no big deal. The only thing offered was to "munch" on the incorrectly made one while we waited. Disappointed in the experience. Everyone else around us that came in after us, was gone when I got my pizza. We ate a slice each and boxed the rest. Definitely not the Hometown Pizza I remember."

"The pizza is delicious here. I enjoyed my meal and found the restaurant clean. The service was very good, quick and efficient and we did not wait long for our food. The manager came by our table to check on us and was very polite and professional. Will definitely eat here again."

"Everyone comes here for the pizza but I want to give recognition to their house salad. I was recently at two big chain restaurants and the salad here at hometown Pizza blows both away. Healthy and plentiful greens with crunchy onion straws to give great texture to the salad. Give it a try, because it's fantastic."

"This is, according to a manager, the typical amount of pepperoni on a single topping pepperoni pizza. The amount of grease on it made it inedible. They gave me a credit for my next visit, which is great, but I'm posting pics so that people are aware when they order. I was told to order 'light pepperoni' next time, but I have a hard time believing this is normal. It was 5-6 pepperoni stacked on top of each other most places, not even separated."