Brothers Pizza Express 2260 Buckthorne Place, The Woodlands, TX 77380

"Having lived in The Woodlands area over 40 years, I know Brothers has a good reputation as a family pizza place putting out quality pies some folks consider to be the most authentic NY style in the area. It has been a longstanding second to Greek Tony's (RIP) through many of the years there wasn't much competition. I've only eaten in the shop a few times and it's fine, but every time I order to go it's just not a good experience, whether waiting for extraordinary amounts of time because they lose the order, or because it's just poorly constructed pizza, or apathy by the people running the business, or all of the above. Tonight, was an all-time low. I typically get cheese or pepperoni, something simple, but tonight we ordered 1/2 deluxe pizza 1/2 margarita and it looked like it had been thrown together in about 20 seconds, they apparently use canned mushrooms and the same Sysco bagged sausage you'll find at Pizza Hut, both are just flat gross. I worked at Pizza Hut as a teen as well as Paradise Pizza (RIP) for a few years so I understand good and bad ingedients. We also ordered a Greek salad, and the peperoncini pepper was old, brown and tasted rancid. Some of the lettuce and onions were likewise brown and old, it was just as bad as the pizza, if not worse. I should have stayed loyal to the always trusty Pizza Tonight, where they turn out fresh pies with fresh ingredients and are always friendly. Kendall cares about his business. I won't go back to Brothers, it just always disappoints and there are too many other good options to support mediocrity. I suppose that may just be what it takes to survive these days..."

"What a fantastic experience! You have to try Brothers Pizza Express. We were greeted like family from the beginning. We drove all the way from Coldspring, TX after hearing how good the pizza was. It’s no joke! It felt as if we were back in time eating at the original Brothers Pizza reading the old news articles on the wall. Mr. Manny even treated us to lunch on his dime. We offered to pay, but he insisted after hearing why we were there today. This is our new FAVORITE pizza place and we will tell everyone to try it ✅ Thank you Mr. Manny for everything."

"This is the 1st time we have tried out Brothers Pizza Express. Man, the staff I met to pick up our order was super chill and outgoing. The Greek Salad was great tasting and full of fresh ingredients. The specialty pizza was very delicious; every slice had the perfect toppings. The X-Large pizzas have ten large slices. We will come back to grub out!!! Thank you for doing an excellent job!!!!"

"not just a pizza, this place serves up an experience. Small hidden place that is genuine to their roots and authentic New York recipe since 1980. Family owned for 43 years. This Grogan's Mills location opened in 1996 and has become a legendary staple for The Woodlands. If you know... you know"

"I heard great things about this place and was really excited to finally see for myself. The pizza is delicious. Reminds me of the pizza I grew up on while living in Massachusetts. We also got an order of buffalo wings and my 7yo son said those wings "changed his life." Haha."