Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge 1101 English Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46203

"Great service - our waitress Cara was very sweet, professional and knowledgeable. The drinks were good as was the food. Live music even though we weren’t expecting to hear any. Definitely enjoyed our experience and would go back. Only reason we didn’t give five stars is because the oysters had a few shells… and weren’t as hot as they should’ve been… and the beef Wellington was overcooked. We also ordered au gratin because we weren’t told our beef came with mashed potatoes."

"Visited with a group of six on a Tuesday evening. The live music, though fantastic, still allowed for comfortable conversations even at a close distance to the stage. The food left us underwhelmed; the wagyu meatball appetizer was cold and tough, while the French onion soup and bread were delightful. Unfortunately, we waited nearly 30 minutes for our main entrees. The steaks were good, complemented by a potent but amazing garlic aioli. However, for a $100 per plate restaurant, the steaks didn't meet the expected quality. Dessert took an additional twenty minutes and was just okay, with average bread pudding. Despite a great atmosphere, we found it overpriced for the overall experience. While trying it once is recommended, our return is uncertain."

"Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge provided an exceptional experience in every aspect. The atmosphere exuded charm with its rustic, dimly lit, and romantic ambiance. The addition of low-volume live music enhanced the overall experience. The service was outstanding, and the food was simply exquisite. The Beef Wellington, along with all the sides, was delightful. I'm already looking forward to my next visit. Highly recommend for a special evening out."

"The entree food was delicious. There was a long wait for the food but the server did tell us the kitchen was behind. The atmosphere was very dim. A bit too dim for my preference. When we were there they had a singer and she was hitting octaves that were quite piercing and even distracting at times. We were seated in the corner upstairs and when we put our elbows on the table the top tipped the whole table. They did not have beer on draft and the desert was mediocre. I didn’t love the bread pudding."

"Went for a birthday dinner. Drinks were not great. Hard to get down, bothe drinks. No one asked if we liked them or checked on us or offered anything else. Dinner was amazing. The chocolate cake was AWFUL. Very dry, icing was hard and sent it back. Again, no one asked if we like it or how it was. They just took it back and then charged us for it. Overall, it is nice but not worth the 200.00+ dollars."