Old City Hall 814 Saginaw Street, Bay City, MI 48708

"We were headed to Gatsby's and found out there was a long wait , and happened to walk by Old City Hall , I. had looked at the reviews in the past but never visited. We walked in and were seated in a few moments. It's a very cool old building like many of these old repurposed buildings are . Our waiter was average , but the wait on our order was extremely lengthy. We had their version of Chicken Marcella and their Sposami Pollo. The Chicken Marcella didn't have the slightest hint of Marcella wine, and although both dishes were edible they were both absolutely mediocre at best. Note to self : next time just be extra patient and wait at Gatsby's."

"My husband & I had lunch at OCH last Saturday. We were the first customers of that day. Brian was our server & was fantastic. He answered our questions, gave suggestions & treated us well. It had been a long time since we had been there because we were not impressed the time. Our lunch was delicious!!! My husband had a club wrap & fries…..he loved it & usually only orders burgers. I had the Harvest Salad & it was so yummy. It was very big & I had leftovers the next day. Highly recommend this place & look forward to going again. Thank you Brian for your great service. Glad they brought you to OCH from their restaurant in Midland. The presentation of the salad was very pretty…..this pic was after I started to mix it up together."

"We love going to Old City Hall for a nice meal. We've been for dinner and lunch. We recently had New Year's Eve dinner with a great server. I liked the new specials they had, we enjoyed ourselves very much. We got the Crab dip, the Swordfish special, the Osso Bucco, and the Beef Tagliata."

"I’m my opinion this is the best restaurant in this town. I had the ahi tuna with in house made nacho chips, horseradish sauce and veggie. It was amazing. Then for my main dish I had blackened salmon with green beans. I too was fantastic. Lastly, for dessert I had the flourless chocolate cake absolutely delicious. The service was great. They take reservations and we didn’t have to wait to be seated. What a great place."

"We sat in the bar area & the bar tender served us. Extremely helpful & knew the menu. I didn't get her name, but she was great at noon today! Loved the cucumber mocktail she suggested. Best food & service we've had in quiet some time! The prime rib sandwich was so good as were the mussels!"