Cagney's Pizza King 33 East Broadway Street, Shelbyville, IN 46176

"The only reason I only gave it for for the atmosphere is because the food doesn't fit. Best pizza could have been sold at the best pizza restaurants ever!! Would have went better with a full bar. Just my opinion. Excellent"

"Pretty bad when the mice under the table dont even want the food on the floor. The food was absolutely Terrible. Service was fine but mozzarella sticks were steaming but not really hot. Aside from the worst chicken bacon ranch I've ever had the food was overpriced and the amount of mice running around under our table was disturbing. The floors were disgusting from I could see behind the counter and I've never been given a drink with the straw already opened and in my drink. I would give no stars for the food if it was an option. The mushrooms on our pizza weren't cooked and it seemed they were taken straight from the can to our finished pizza. Food was nasty and we will definitely stick with Rushville Pizza King from now on.!"

"Love Cagney’s for many years! Great pizzas (personal favorite-BLT PIZZA), great sandwiches & specials M-F. Fast service, pleasant employees & the best fountain Cokes!"

"Every time I order it gets here faster than it says and it's always hot and fresh. Very happy with the service and it's cheaper to have delivered than the big box store chains. I appreciate this part very much! Second time this week I ordered!"

"We stopped by Cagneys for supper. No wait for seating. They were busy but not extremely. I ordered a pizza with pepperoni & extra cheese, Judy got a Stromboli & fries instead of their usual chips. Our server was efficient and polite."