Jimmy John's 11630 Olio Road, Fishers, IN 46037

"I love Jimmy John’s, their sandwiches are great and the service is fast and convenient. The only problem is this location is the complete opposite of that. Every time I order either delivery or pickup from this location my order is incorrect. And if it’s delivery it takes a minimum of 30 mins to get my order, despite the fact that I live close to the store. I ordered a #11 with no tomatoes. Apparently the employees there thought that meant to just put lettuce on bread and send it to me. I will never order from this store again."

"I had a catering order that was suppose to be ready at 10:30am, right when the store opened. When I arrived to pick up my order (that was called in days ago) it wasn’t ready. I waited 20 minutes in the store before my order was ready. I was in a time crunch because we needed the food for an event at 11. So I was late to the event. What is the point of calling and ordering ahead with a specified time if you aren’t going to follow it? Won’t be returning to this specific Jimmy John’s."

"So, I very rarely write poor reviews (as you can see in my profile), but I’ve noticed such a change in this place over the years. Lived in Fishers for 20 years. Been going to this location since it opened. The last 6-12 months this is what I’ve noticed… -Prices keep going up. I get everything is becoming more expensive, but from a percentage standpoint, they’ve taken huge increases. -Portions keep going down. The last BLT I ordered, truly had to do a double take. Bread was very small, toppings were limited. It was noticeably 20-30% smaller than what the average used to be. You can’t cut portion size, then increase costs and expect to keep loyal customers. -Lettuce has gotten really bad. At times brown, and an odd taste. I’ve thought about just asking them to no longer put lettuce on my sandwich, but then it just gets even smaller. -Service is a lot slower. Never used to wait more than a minute or two for a sandwich. Waiting 5+ minutes now is common. I guess that wouldn’t be bad if the business hadn’t been built on speed and quality. The freaky fast has been absent for a long time now. Additionally, a lot of these workers look at you like a deer in headlights when you come to the register. Often times there’s very little speech directed towards you. The other night 5 people behind the counter and after 30 seconds they yelled at the guy sweeping the floor to come ring me up. Poor kid had very bad communication skills. Like I said, I don’t like to write negative reviews, but this location has gotten noticeably worse and worse. For the increased prices I expect more and for the time being will shift to Potbelly. Hopefully a manager is reading this and can turn it around. I’ll give it a try in a few months and see."

"The Lettuce delivered on my sandwich should have been discarded days ago. Manager is correcting the issue. However, beware."

"Typical Jimmy Johns food and service. The indoor seating is in a long narrow and somewhat dark and uninving hallway en route to the restroom with no rear store exit door. So a bit of a dead end floor plan style is awkward. 3 sandwiches $30 is starting to makr JJ’s a bit expensive withit being a meal deal. But the food is consistent across stores."