Papa Johns Pizza 9669 Olio Road, McCordsville, IN 46055

"Are all Papa John’s this terrible? I doubt if I ever go back to any Papa John store. I called about an hour and a half before I could pick it up and they apparently went ahead and cooked it and threw it in a corner and it was stale and cold when I got there. Never going back and don’t ever order a thin crust pizza unless you like it paper thin and like a cracker."

"My husband picked up a pizza that we ordered on the website. My order was wrong! When he arrived, he was supposed to wait at the door until they brought his order out. No one came out for a long time so he went in. When he got in the store the employee would not help him. One employee was deaf and wanted to help but could not. The other employee was extremely rude and ignored several customers/ Uber drivers who were clearly waiting in line to pick up their pizzas. When my husband asked about his order, at first he said that the pizza wasn't there at all. Then, he double checked and it was. My pizza had also been made 25 minutes prior to scheduled pickup time, so by the time it got home, it was quite cold. Toppings and seasoning packets that we paid for were missing. When I tried to call, the employees kept picking up and putting the phone back on hold without even speaking with me. I am extremely disappointed and will never order from this particular store ever again. I've ordered from other stores and had wonderful experiences. I understand having a bad day but when an employee makes everybody else's day bad because doesn't like his job, he should probably find a different one."

"Just received delivery pizza for the first time from this location. Also, haven't eaten Papa John's in years. Please tell me where's the meat. Ordered pepperoni and sausage with vegs. Each slice had one pepperoni and one sausage nugget. Maybe this why we stopped ordering from Papa John's. Perhaps for a free charitable pizza this would be okay.This so unacceptable for a paid pizza. Again. One pepperoni and one sausage nugget per slice. If this is not the pizza making process for this location, please get another pizza maker and thoroughly train him or her. The pizza was not free, but should have been."

"I ordered a pizza for delivery but it was delivered through a 3rd party. My pizza said delivered but I didn’t receive it. Idk if neighbors took it or the driver just up and stole it, but Andrew at the store was super cool about it. Andrew was super helpful and made me a new one and hand delivered it to me in like 20 mins tops. Even threw in an extra butter and upgraded me to stuffed crust at no extra charge. Andrew is a hoss and I appreciate him being so friendly and helpful! Best experience at a Papa Johns ever! Thanks, brother!"