Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington 4155 Boulevard Place, Indianapolis, IN 46208

"I grew up going to Philly and eating cheesesteaks , finding a place with an authentic cheesesteaks is impossible till today!! Stopped in and besides being in Philly best cheesesteak hands down .. all the Philly decor is like your stepping into a sandwich shop in downtown Philly … all they need is some scrapple so I don’t have to order it from Amazon … A++++++++ definitely my new spot ! Can’t wait for my mother to come visit from Michigan as she grew up in downtown Philly . Been trying to get her to open a shop like this in Michigan for years …"

"5 stars all the way. Don’t sleep on this place. Nestled in an unassuming neighborhood close to Butler is this gem. Fresh rolls and cold cuts shipped in frequently make this place a cut above the rest. I had the Philly cheesesteak, wit(h) and wiz. Very close to actual Phillys. Onion rings were great as well. Atmosphere is great and service was top notch. I will be back!"

"We are in town for a soccer tournament this weekend and found this absolute gem in our Google search results. Honestly the first good cheesesteak I've had since moving from the eastern PA area into the cheesesteak desert known as Louisville. This was a true oasis after so many failed attempts to find authentic cheesesteak within driving distance. We'll be back for sure, especially for the ones with their house made spicy red sauce! The atmosphere was great and we especially liked the PA touch to all the decor. The only thing that could've really taken this over the top is if they also offered pierogies as a side and a Kutztown soda. Thanks for bringing us back home, Hoagies and Hops."

"Ordered a regular cheesesteak - ribeye, grilled onion and provolone (didn’t want cheese wiz today). The atmosphere is relaxed, but the actual cheesesteak had no flavor. The steak didn’t taste like anything, quite unseasoned. The grilled onions were muted in terms of flavor, and in general my sub was dry."

"Incredible! I made this place my last meal before jaw surgery and it did not disappoint. Easily the best cheese steaks in Indiana. One of the rare places that actually does whiz wit. Great beer too!"