Bella Pizzeria - Noblesville

"As a native New Yorker, I must express my profound disappointment with the misrepresentation of this pizza as "New York" styled. The excessively moist and disheveled cheese, along with the inadequately cooked crust, falls short of the mark for discerning aficionados of authentic New York pizza. However, it's worth noting that when the pizza is cooked thoroughly, it does exhibit a modest improvement in flavor that may resemble a nostalgic New York Slice."

"We moved to the area from Long Island, New York in 2021, and have been searching for an authentic NY pizza since we arrived. Our search is over. The moment we opened the box, we knew. Even our 6 year old granddaughter said it “smelled like New York pizza!” The crust was just the right thickness, perfectly cooked. The sauce was nice and fresh. Oh, and the oregano? Not too little, not too much. Perfection! Our only regret was not ordering two. We will definitely be back for more. Thank you! You made these ex-New Yorkers very happy."

"We love the Bella for Two special. The team there is always very friendly and we love the pizza. It’s also great that we can get red peppers as a topping. Yum!"

"It’s not the best slice in town but it’s okay. Salad with ranch was good, breadsticks and cheese dip is 5 stars. The pizza needs a more crispy bottom, more cheese at the top, but flavor is good. 6.5 would be my score."

"We happened to be heading back to Indy on I-69 and we needed a few things so shopped at the Hamilton Town Center. Lunch was in the air and we landed at the outdoor food court and decided to continue our search for exemplary pizza . Well, we finally had some very good pizza. It is NY style pizza, large slices and warmed up to order. We opted for a couple of the Combo #2s at around $7.50 each with a small salad, soda and a slice of pizza of our choice. My partner went with the margherita slice and I went with the supreme. Both were superb with just the right crust thickness, a slight crunch on bottom and done all the way through . The margherita had distinct garlic overtones along with the tomatoes and cheese. The supreme has green peppers , mushroom and pepperoni. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. These slices' ingredients were fully integrated and each bite was wonderful. So many pizzas are prepared and come out like you're eating a pizza crust with toppings that seem like they are a separate dimension to the crust. These were a perfect balance of crust thickness , sauce and toppings. Highly recommend this pizza ."