Pizza House 11 North Main Street, Cicero, IN 46034

"Probably the last visit to the Pizza House. Cheese on top was just a solid slab. Not really sure what kind of cheese it was. Was not "pully" (daughter's word) like melted mozzarella. For the money, there is most definitely better pizza out there. Tried to give them one last shot, but nope."

"The pizza itself if great. We truly have no complaints there but the last 7-8 times we have ordered we have either a) gotten the wrong pizza not the end of the world , b ) we order knowing it’s a 55-65 minute wait time , and we end up waiting another 15 minutes ontop of that, again not the end of the world or c) like tonight we had both. We arrived at the 65 minute mark , my husband went inside to get the pizza , they had no idea where the ticket went or they weren’t sure if the pizza was taken by the delivery guy , so we had to wait another 15-20 minutes for them to make our order , only to get home and we got the wrong pizza . The staff is friendly and nice, also young so we try to give it a lot of grace and The girl did credit us 10$ tonight . But 55$ is a lot of money to spend on 1 X-Large house speciality pizza , 1 small plain cheese pizza and an order of breadsticks and we constantly have the same issue ."

"What a great find I enjoy a good pizza but when you find a great pizza that is unique and flavorful that makes for a fantastic night. Make sure to add on a brownie pizza or two for dessert as well. Had a deluxe pizza, Hawaiian pizza, along with breadsticks, cinnamon sticks, and a brownie pizza. Everything was delicious and service was outstanding. Also while I was there I noticed a lot of phone in orders so if you are in a hurry just call it in or jump online to place your order to take home."

"It was nice to see a staff work together and actually socializing with one another. Seems like a fun place to work. I ordered a cauliflower crust pizza and before they started making it our server came back and asked if it was for allergies so they took extra precautions. (It was so I was appreciative of that!!) They also have cards at the table to play while waiting for pizza. It was our first time there and we will definitely return. Tony was an amazing server!"

"Great food! Under new ownership, Craig, and wow can you tell a difference! The quality has improved, flavors and the time it takes to receive your food is faster. They even have a great new outdoor patio! We stopped coming here because it just wasn’t the same with the previous owner. So glad we tried it again, our favorite pizza place is back and better than ever! Thank you Craig for all the improvements!"