Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood

"Was looking forward to New York style pizza. Guess you only get that if you order by the slice. Would have been helpful to know that beforehand. Pizza could do without the oregano, as could the breadsticks…there are other better flavors to use. Pizza was ok and the breadsticks were pretty decent, just leave out the oregano. Breadsticks are pretty decent size too, you could manage with one per person unless you’re starving! Cheese sauce and garlic butter were very tasty! Staff was friendly, place was super small though, just a few tables. Remember, if you want NY style, order by the slice!! Might go back to try again!"

"Great New York style pizza. As a New Yorker, I grew up on pizza by the slice. The atmosphere is great. Great service, and more importantly, the food is great. Great variety of pies as well."

"If you want a New York slice this is it. There's plenty of pizza around but this place is all about New York style. The pizza is always consistent and good. The staff is beyond excellent. Highly recommended."

"Easy online ordering, ready to go at pickup time and delicious. Got the Vinny (white) pizza and added aun dried tomatoes. Delicious thin NY crust. Garlic olive oil sauce was flavorful but not overpowering. Cheese was piled high. Breadsticks in the case looked delicious. Will be back to try more."

"Best Pizza in Bloomington! You can get a slice or order an entire pizza. The pizzas take about 15 minutes but that is not too bad. The prices are also very reasonable, especially for it being on Kirkwood. Plus they are open late! The breadstick is huge and tastes amazing! The staff were very friendly and the line moves quickly."