Aurelio's Pizza of Schererville

"Possibly the best Aurellios pizza we’ve had. Loaded with sausage and pepperoni and a little extra cooked. And wonderful and prompt service tonight. Thank you MISSY F!!! Amazing!"

"never thought I would say this about pizza BUT this is the nastiest pizza I ever had! the sauce and sausages nasty, cheese seem like they did some type of mixture. The pizza didn’t even look good! will not revisit"

"Called and made reservations for 630. Got there and table wasn't ready. They had to split r party in different tables. There was 15 of us. Some of the draft beer tasted like they haven't cleaned their beer lines in awhile. Server acted like she didn't know what was going on. The whole place was ran by teenagers. Didn't see one person that looked over 18 that was working. Server was not very attentive. Saw her hanging with people in the front. She didn't bring us the food it was someone else. When she asked who got certain things she just sat it in front of other people even after we told her who got it. Salad had alot of brown pieces, pizza was very doughy like it wasn't cooked long enough. Part of our pizza had no cheese or toppings on it. The tortellini was crunchy and not cooked all the way. On the menu it stated it came with garlic bread. Asked the server and was told it didn't. Server never once took any dirty or empty plates or cups off our table. Needed Togo boxes. Couldn't find server so went up front. Had to ask the person 3 times for the right containers for someone to then tell me oh u need to ask ur servers for that stuff. When they were literally right next to the Togo stuff. Server never came so another lady finally brought us what we needed. Most of the party was standing around trying to leave when the server finally came with the check. Horrible service and food. Won't be back."

"I never thought i would stop here, but i am now a fan. We walked in, 1st thing that hit us was a bad smell of old mop water ( not good). We was seated and ordered a 1/2 sausage 1/2 pepperoni that was tasty and crunchy thin Judy how i liked it. A side salad to match, but the dressing was not so good. She brought me this large side salad, that's good but it was on a small plate food was spulling from the sides. The French dressing had some kind of pineapples in it, i should have been told that first. The bathroom is a 1 door, 1 stall place not good. But since they are a pizza joint, the pizza was AMAZING, I'll probably go back just for a carry out tho."