AJ's Pizza Co 3050 Matson Street, Chesterton, IN 46304

"1st time here, so kinda limited in what we tried from the menu. Great pizza! The crust is a bit crunchy, but soft inside. Wonderful!! The toppings were nice and fresh and plentiful. A good amount of cheese on the pizza too. Not skimpy, but not overwhelming either, just right. Also tried the Spinach Galette, which was awesome!!! and the onion rings are good, but the onions themselves (inside the onion rings) were a bit tough to bite through. Good flavor and crunch on the breading though. 2 kinds of Italian sausage ( 1 mild, the other slightly spicy), but with big containers of crushed red pepper on the table, a bit more heat is never TOO far away!"

"Go for the thin crust and the bread twists. Service and atmosphere and food were excellent, but per my taste the red sauce is a little too sweet."

"A wonderful “home town” pizza place in an upgraded location. Very friendly waitstaff. They have the usual pizza place offerings with a fantastic craft beer selection and delicious gluten free crust option."

"Pizza was good. Arguably a little undercooked. I’d recommend that you ask for yours extra crispy. Salad was basic, the croutons were mid. For sure came out of some kind of packaging. They were tiny which was kinda cute tho. The chocolate cake was actually really good tho. Like to die for good. Our waiter was what made this review 5 starts. Fantastic service. Casey took the time to get to know us. That was awesome."

"Really great experience! Excited to come again and again! The service is the reason for 5 stars. Casey was incredible. She was attentive and focused. Sarcastic and funny as well. The salads were good, great dressings. The wings were okay, the sauce wasn’t hot (temperature wise). The pizza. I highly recommend you get the thing crust and that you ask for extra crispy! The people could of been cooked more. The desserts were amazing! The cheesecake was my favorite! Great employees make great restaurants. The food is only part of it. We’ll done AJ’s!"