Cottage Inn Pizza Mt. Pleasant 1639 East Broomfield Street, Mount Pleasant, MI 48858

"Girlfriend ordered takeout in-store yesterday, October 31st, 2023. She wanted a ham and cheese SUB, and repeated it 4 times over their loud and obnoxious music, and instead gave her a ham and cheese pizza. How do you mess that up? Not to mention, I ordered a Philly Cheese steak sub, specifically without mushrooms because they are disgusting, and they still mashed em in. Not ordering from here again."

"Cottage Inn deep dish is always great! I order from the Mt. Pleasant MI Cottage Inn about once a month, and the food is always fresh, hot, and great. My family loves everything we've ever ordered from Cottage Inn. From the breadsticks, the garlic cheese bread, the calzones, the deep dish pizza, even salads! Always good!"

"Was visiting Soaring Eagle and got a carry out from here and omgsh the Calzone was amazing. I ordered Alfredo sauce Chicken Bacon Mushrooms. By far the best I’ve had"

"Disclaimer: Ive only tried the sandwiches. I've only had delivery so far and they've always been on time thus far, so I really appreciate their effort. I have tried 3 sandwiches: Philly Steak Supreme: Pretty decent. I like the flavor of the meat and the pepperoncini. I think they could probably add more flavor to the mushroom and bell pepper, but still it tastes good with the included side of ranch. Chicken Parmesan Sub: Cannot recommend it. The red sauce they use is too sweet. The cheese blend is not bad. The chicken unfortunately just seems like deep fried nuggets, so it seems to be slapped together very quickly (sauce, chicken, and cheese); the nuggets don't have a bad taste, but the red sauce they use ruins it for me. Could be cheaper if it's just 4 ingredients. Cottage Inn Club Sub: If you ask for extra mustard, this is a really nice sandwich when warm. Actually it's almost like any sandwich u can make at home, but the 1 foot is just nice for when you're lazy and want something simple (probably best with a coupon). I do feel that, for the time invested in these meals (some of these can be slapped together in less than 5 mins), the prices could be a little cheaper. Ideally I'd rate them 3.5/5"

"Just called to order The Family Meal Deal. Was told that with coupon I had to order on line. Person on phone did try to place my order, but said it wouldn't go thru and I would have to place order on line. I told him that no where on the coupon does it say order had to be place on line. I told him that I would order pizza somewhere else. We do like Cottage Inn, have eaten it for years but if you can't honor your own coupons then I'm going elsewhere."