East of Chicago Pizza 350 South Van Buren Street, Shipshewana, IN 46565

"Very disappointed. Came for the buffet, left to go get fast food. Old pizza on the buffet, never stocked it up. Paid $14 for a Pepsi. Great!"

"They start with a pre made crust, add very little Sauce and Toppings Hardly any flavor! I'll never buy there again. A Frozen Pizza from Dollar General is a better choice!"

"Have been a different time and did the pizza buffet and wasn't overly impressed with options, food was kinda dry. But most recently made a carryout order and a fresh made pizza from here is exceptional. We will be returning customers. Pictured are parm pops and the chicken bacon ranch pizza with stuffed crust. My husband really liked the marinara, and the cheese sauce was good too."

"To start. The lady on the phone was very knowledgeable. She knew the menu and prices without missing a beat. The food was ready and fantastic. Hot and fresh. The crust was very well made. And the sauce was incredible. Great job. I'm hype about a good pizza place!"

"The best deep dish pizza our family has ever tried. We visited here when we were staying in Shipshewana and it is now a family favorite. The deep dish pizza is so good and the garlic cheese bread is amazing! We also love the Parm pops with marinara sauce. The prices are very reasonable and everything is always fresh. They also have a buffet but we were not there when it was running. If you go at lunchtime, they have the perfect size personal pizzas called flash pan pizza. Highly recommended! If we lived closer, this would be our go to pizza place!"