Millie's Glen Arbor

"Delicious pizza place. We’ve been coming up here for years and this might be one of the best pizzas in the area that I’ve had. It’s Detroit style. We got a pepperoni and cheese and fungi add cheese. And Cesar salad. The pepperoni is crispy and slightly spicy (nothing bad but might be intense for kids). The red sauce wasn’t overly acidic. Which I appreciated. The fungi add cheese with garlic was great too. As for the salad I could taste the anchovy in the dressing which was a welcome surprise that they’re doing it right!"

"Came here August 23, 2023. Meant to always post a review. It was such a memorable poor experience we started talking about it today so I finally decided to post a review I always intended. The pizza was like Jets pizza but with better ingredients however the pricing was outrageous. The slice size was half of a normal Jets pizza slice. The pizza price per slice was the equivalent to New York City pricing except in New York you can actually call it a meal. On top of all of this we noticed we were going to get multiple slices together. Back then the menu said you could order per slice or get what seemed to be a full pizza because most pizzas normally do cost $20-25. So we went for that option. When we received the order and opened the box we were quickly disappointed to find out it was 4 slices that you could barely add up to what was normally half a pizza anywhere else. I forgot to mention changing our minds from switching from slices to what seemed to be a full pizza, we were met with frustration from the workers about changing the order in the system while we were still being rung up. It’s not like we even paid yet. For the quantity you get here they have to display the amount you will receive because this was a shock to the 4 of us. We keep bringing this bad experience up to so many friend groups and I always remember I intended to write a review because the experience felt so unfair. Not cool."

"We’re based locally and tried Millie’s for the first time over Labor Day Weekend with our family. The location cannot be beat, and we were able to head over after a 3 hour paddle down the Crystal River. I was so glad the shop mirrored the previous restaurant in that it was small and cozy with plenty of outdoor seating facing the river. The model of this business, with a limited menu and sold by the slice may be unfamiliar but honestly it’s really refreshing and easy. There are two dozen other pizza places in the area when you can get a Double Cheeseburger Chicken Buffalo Pizza and if that’s your thing by all means get it, but if you have a love for really simple and good ingredients and Detroit deep dish pizza I think you’ll love this. The sauce stood out the most for its tangy-ness and we loved the classic pepperoni that curls up at the side. A huge bonus was that the pizzas were prepared in the morning fresh and so ordering is super quick and efficient. Our relatives thought the price point was a bit high but $25 feels really reasonable for a delicious and super filling pizza. 2 heavy and topping- laden pizzas will fill you up, and if they do ever expand their menu I’m sure the others will be awesome as well. We can officially say this is one of the top 5 pizza places in the region in our books and plan to make it a weekly thing. Folks who say this pizza is unaffordable seem to think eating out and buying food from a restaurant isn’t a luxury, and a $6 slice of good pizza still rings true to the area, both for tourists and locals I believe. Definitely recommend checking this place out, I don’t think you’ll be disappointed!"

"I disagree with some of the other reviews. So delicious and the location can’t be beat right along the river. Generous sized portions, deep dish Detroit style. We had two slices each and felt satisfied Loved the classic pepperoni and homemade ice cream. Can’t wait to come back!!"

"First time trying Millie’s and it will be our last. We live in Glen Arbor, and are very disappointed (picture attached) 1) $5 a slice?? How’s a family supposed to be able to afford those prices? 2) The Pizza was terribly greasy and there are only 4 types to pick from, and already cooked before hand. It was burnt & dried out. We miss Johnnies Riverside Pizza. Bear Paw across the street or Market 22 will be getting our business."