Yankee Rebel Tavern

"We were a group of 7 on the very busy final Saturday on the island. It was very busy but our waitress was very sharp and friendly with all of our variety of food and drink requests. The whitefish bites were delicious. Everyone else enjoyed their meals and pictures are attached. We will return next June for sure during Lilacfest!"

"The atmosphere is nice here. Cute place. Warm and inviting. We had the white fish and the 1/2 order of pot roast. The 1/2 order of pot roast could have fed 3 people. The meat was tender. Don't change a thing Yankee Rebel!"

"We came here for an early dinner and were not disappointed. My wife had pistachio crusted whitefish and I had the herb crusted salmon with a blue cheese/Wasabi baked top. So good!! The staff was very friendly and pleasant. Great place!!"

"I hate hate hate that you can't make reservations unless you are a group of 6 or more. This whole place has a very 80s-90s vibe starting with you have to wait around for your table to be called. The hostess was professional but wow she has a hard job. We tried so hard to get in to eat here since my dad had been raving about the Caesar salad and pot roast... The place is super loud. Really cramped, the decor has not been updated at all, but why would you if you're that busy. Honestly, the wine list was nice, I really enjoyed the California red zin that we got. The server seemed exhausted but he did a good job. The Caesar salad must have been made by someone different because it was really soupy. The pot roast meat was also cooked to death. Overall, this place reminded me of Applebee's... My partner and I each got a Delmonico steak because we thought that seems like something fun to order. It was cooked correctly, but sliced the wrong way so each bite was incredibly tough to eat. Not sure i would eat here again unless early or late in the season. Not a restful experience. Oh and you had to leave your stroller out front on the sidewalk."

"Wonderful welcoming tavern, warm comfy ambience. Excellent hearty fare. Atlantic Salmon in Balsamic glaze sone of the best I’ve ever had. Great staff. Place was full all night but never felt too crowded or loud…just happy. Nice bar, always full."