The Pickled Herring,

1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814, United States

"Can’t say enough about the food! The blackened whitefish and homemade “chips” with homemade mild horseradish sauce … OMG! Great service, nice atmosphere; clean and music at a level that you can hold a conversation easily. I’ll be back!"

"Service was okay. The food was below average. Plus extra fees? I ordered the broiled white fish platter for $27 and the fish had bones and tasted like smelly pond water. I asked for a new dish after trying a couple bites. The next piece was better but still not great. The sides were average, nothing was fresh. I had asked for an extra plate as my fiance and I we were splitting some things and they charged $2 for an extra plate on the ticket. I will not be going back overpriced and the food was just blah."

"Dined here twice, first dinner outside. Good food, good service at a relaxed pace with a nice view of the harbor. Bottom bun if the burger was very soggy. Second lunch inside, food was excellent, but very slow, probably 30+ minutes after we ordered, for poutine and a sandwich. We sat next to the door and there were quite a few flies, much louder than outside, also took quite a while to find our waiter for our check after we finished. Over probably 4.5 dinner outside, 3 lunch inside."

"Waiting for our cruise we decided to get a bite at The Pickeld Herring to hold us over until dinner. We split the Wisconsin Poutine and they charged us $2 for the extra plate! I mean come on. That's so cheesy. And the food is overpriced... but that's the case just about everywhere... not that that's justification. After the cruise we returned for "dinner" at 8 p.m. and we both had the fish and fries. It was good. Giving it 4 stars cause the food was good as was the scenery from the patio."

"Had lunch here and both of us got the fish and fries. The food was delicious! The whitefish was fried perfectly and not greasy at all. The fries were also perfect. Why the four stars instead of five? Because our waiter never once returned to check on us or offer refills on our drinks. Not even when he cleared our plates did he offer a refill. The place was busy, but not swamped, so that’s not as excuse."