Cosentino Pizzeria 4139 Tallmadge Road, Rootstown, OH 44272

"Amazing food! Love the pizza and the pasta and appetizers, haven’t found anything I didn’t like. The Hoho cake is my favorite. If I could have something from here every day, I would! Love love, love.!!! Jill"

"Veggie pizza cauliflower crust is the best. we also like the pepperoni cauliflower cheese. The calzone and pasta are amazing. They are the nicest people and pizza restaurant in the area hands down"

"Excellent food and service! The food is always fresh and made from scratch. They have very good prices a good variety of options on their menu. They also provide a great catering options for bigger parties. Consentinos is a gem in our area."

"Awesome quality food. If you love top quality food for a great affordable price this is your place. Every dish is handmade from scratch, the Chef has years of experience and takes his food quality serious. Don't listen to the nonsense reviews, these people give, give, give to the community and only care about making customers happy with their food. If you have a issue call them and I guarantee you they will do whatever they can to make it right. If I were able to eat this food daily I would honestly probably buy a dinner every night! Dinner, pizza, whatever is on the menu is delicious. Do yourself a favor and go grab a pizza, but if you're expecting a chain restaurant style pizza then this isn't your place."

"Not sure how they get so many 5 star reviews. Food we got was awful it gave me terrible heartburn and kind of sick to my stomach. Had to throw almost all of it in the trash. This is not an exaggeration, Little Caesars is way better and with more toppings! I hate to leave bad reviews but when it is so bad you cant sleep after eating it i feel like i have to warn people. I am writing this at 3:00 am!"