Checker's Pizza 139 West Herrick Avenue, Wellington, OH 44090

"Our go-to pizza place. Our whole family loves it"

"Ordered pizza at 4:30 to be delivered to work by 5:55. Pizza arrived at 6:30, the end of my break. And it was stone cold. Never again!"

"What a horrible experience! They said it'd be ready in 45-50 minutes, I went in at 60 minutes, paid and waited 15 minutes while they looked for my food. After I asked 5 minutes later they finally told me they were starting my order then!! Needless to say I asked for a refund and left. While waiting I watched a couple employees touching dirty items and then touching raw food. The whole place was dirty and gross. This was the first and last time I'll ever go there."

"If you’ve seen any of my other pizza reviews, you’ll know that I’m on the hunt for NY style pizza in Ohio. Been disappointed so far, and this one was the worst, regardless what type pizza it’s being compared to. Besides the fact that when I asked for garlic knots I was given cheesy garlic bread (there are no garlic knots), and when I asked for a pizza with chicken, bacon, and bbq sauce I was given one with pineapple as well (apparently that’s their special), here is the grading of the pizza itself: Cheese 1/5- very bad mouth feel. Too much cheese/crust ratio. Crust 1/5 - I don’t know if I’d call this pizza crust. It’s more like a really thick, unsweetened, tart crust. It seems as if there’s no raising agent in the dough. The edge crust seems to only have height from being built that way, not from rising. Very crunchy, no air at all. The bottom crust has no form. So incredibly thin it just flops. That’s not what “thin crust” means. Can’t critique the sauce since we got a bbq pizza. The bbq sauce alone though was an issue. WAY too sweet. I don’t know if it was from the bbq, but the pizza was oddly pink, like a bathroom from the 80’s. They did remake the pizza, without the pineapple. No refund though. We definitely will not be coming here again. The search continues."