Dale's Pizza (Hagerstown, IN) 75 West Main Street, Hagerstown, IN 47346

"Burnt quesadilla not once but twice"

"We got a takeout pizza. The pizza was barely warm even though we were there at the appropriate time we were told. The edges of the pizza were soggy. Not a very appetizing pizza at all. Very disappointed"

"I grew up with Dale's pizza. Always love it. Stopped last week. Always try to get a depth charge. They have shrunk them considerably. Still tastes good but too small."

"We have eaten here two days in a row because of how good the food is and all the options. The very first time we had ever had food here was a pickup order, and we have been so disheartened because they were out of chicken wings. We weren't in the mood for pizza then, so we got sandwiches and they were absolutely delicious. We have been working on moving into a home near the area so we thought we would go find some local grub. We decided we would eat here because we had never been inside other than to pick our food up. The inside is very pretty and cozy, and we were really excited that you could order beer here. We got wings, cheesy garlic bread, and a black and blue burger. The wings are ginormous and such good quality, cooked all the way through perfectly and not too chewy. They were actually crispy. The only thing we wished was that they were dredged or tossed in sauce rather than the sauce being dumped on top. A bit too saucy on some wings because of the sauce dump. The cheesy garlic bread was crazy good, and they have delicious marinara for dipping. The burger had some of the best tasting ground beef we've had in sometime. You could tell it was hand pressed, and we liked that. Very flavorful and a good salty bitey blue cheese. Highly recommend. Fries were good n crispy too. The next day we ordered bread sticks and a large pizza. The bread sticks were golden and buttery, with a good chew. We got the Dales pizza with all the fixings, felt appropriate since just trying them out. It had fine ground sausage and big circular pepperoni. To me, for us, there should be no other way lol. This is the best way to have these meat toppings! It also had big pieces of Canadian bacon, green & black olives, green bell pepper, and a crazy massive amount of sliced white onions. We are onion lovers so for us the onions were like the cherry on top. They were sweet and still had a bit of a crisp texture. The crust & sauce was perfect, and whatever cheese they use is the best pizza cheese. It stayed soft, didn't turn into wax consistency like so many other pizza joints do. Absolutely recommend getting a pizza. We will be back! There's more items to try ! Also, we had a different waitress each day, both were so friendly and personable. The people working the counter were also friendly. Bathrooms are clean and spacious. The garlic bread and breadsticks appetizer servings are perfect for 2 hungry people, so if coming with a group consider getting more appetizers. But the actual meal servings are plenty! We got the 16 inch pizza and we both ate 3 meals off of it, so good for 6 people in our opinion."

"Tried it last night for the first time. Really enjoyed it. Friendly people, nice atmosphere, pizza had plenty of toppings. For my taste I would like a bit more sauce and cheese but I can never have enough cheese. Def plan on going back."