Dutch Valley Restaurant 1343 Old Route 39 Northeast, Sugarcreek, OH 44681

"We had the buffet lunch which included a salad buffet and assorted meats and vegetables and a couple desserts. The salad buffet was very nice. I love their broccoli salad. I also had boasted chicken. The noodles and mashed potatoes with gravy were a little bland. I enjoyed the bread pudding. They have a bakery, but we thought the prices were a little high."

"Went for breakfast because the restaurant had gotten a good rating. I was disappointed. My wife got the buffet - her eggs were brown from being overcooked and her breakfast potatoes had little to no taste. I had pancakes,and they were both doughy/sticky in the middle - and barely warm to boot."

"Always love taking a quick trip to Amish country to go to Dutch Valley Restaurant! Food is always clean, delicious and freshly homemade! The service is always gracious and wonderful."

"Overall, it was a good experience. Tge staff were friendly, but the waiter constantly walked past us and didn't ask us if we needed a refill even after I put my glass to the side...needless to say I had to wave her down 5 times everytime I wanted a drink. The overall environment was classier and much more upscale than I expected, but the restaurant still managed to keep that cute amish charm. Most of the food was good, besides the cream corn, which was shockingly bland, and the ham, which had a good flavor but had extremely tough skin and was overcooked overall. The broiled chicken, dressing, and bread pudding was definitely the best off of their dinner bar. Overall, I'd eat here again, just not so close to the kitchen where the waitresses seem to ignore people."

"Another great and delicious find. Took our Grandson to Amish Country, he fell in love with the food, people and area as we had ten years ago. Still finding new spots to eat, love it! Cleanest buffet I've eaten at. Fresh, not salty, the food was beautiful. Could not get enough of, all of it! Great experience. Be back soon for sure. 5 Yuma for sure."