Carfagna's Ristorante 1440 Gemini Place, Columbus, OH 43240

"Love this place! The food was delicious from the appetizers to the main course and the dessert. Had a great bottle of wine too. Our server was friendly and fun. Love how spacious this place is. Didn’t get to shop in the market but looking forward to going back."

"Our server was super friendly, fast and kind. The atmosphere was nice. Comfortable seating and nice mello music. I hate giving bad reviews but honestly, The food was sub par. The vodka sauce and carbonara both tasted ... I'm not sure exactly .... Packaged? Canned? Flavorless? Pasta was overcooked and mushy. Butter was not real butter. All in all ... Just would not recommend."

"My wife and I ate a late lunch here on Black Friday, 2023, around 135pm. Service: The hostess wasn't really friendly. No smile and didn't greet us. She took us to a table and walked off. I'm assuming she didn't want to be there on the day after Thanksgiving, maybe. The waitress was a little better. She was polite and friendly enough. Food: Free bread and garlic butter were very good. My wife ordered gnocchi with pomodora sauce, and it was delicious. I asked for Chicken Parmigiano with spaghetti. The noodles texture was as if they were sitting on a pot all day. Not al dente. The chicken was excellent; crispy on the outside breading and juicy inside. Sauce wasn't anything special. We also each ordered the Italian wedding soup. The gentleman who brought them out spilled mine a little, and he didn't acknowledge nor apologize. It was flavorful. Atmosphere: the seats were dirty and had straw wrapper pieces and I thought perhaps it was an oversight from the busboy cleaning the tables but as I watched him clear the other tables, I noticed he only wiped off the tables and not the seats. The music and ambiance were fine. Overall, i liked the place. I'd come back for the food, but the hostess and cleanliness could be better."

"Carfagna's had the best Italian food in Columbus! I love all of their pastas, and they also have very good appetizers. The atmosphere is great, the staff are all nice, and the portion size is hearty. I would recommend this to anyone who is looking for tasty authentic Italian food without the outrageous prices."

"Really cool location! We stopped there on a slow Saturday afternoon. While the waitress was very nice, she barely stopped by our table. She never brought us bread or refills. Luckily, we tracked down another associated to get us some bread and garlic butter- it was very good! I got chicken parmigiana & a side salad with the house dressing- it was okay but didn’t finish it. While it was an okay experience, we probably won’t stop back, but a really cool place. I will say, we sampled their pizza and it was delicious! Overall, good, not amazing."