Augie's Pizza & Catering

"I eat a lot of pizza and have tried many many places in Ohio. This is the 1st time trying since moving to area. We are 5 minutes away so we wanted to try it. Rated it a solid C+ Family Special ordered - Regular, Pepperoni, Onions, Mama D's Italian Dressing, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Diet Coke 2-Liter, Marinara. Online ordered for 5PM pickup. I was 6 minutes early but pizza must have been sitting out for 20-30 minutes. Pizza cheese started about 2.5" from crust. Fast transaction and friendly kids behind counter. Cheese was solid. They forgot side of sauce. Balsamic was just ok, but wine and vinegar was subpar. We used our own dressing on salad. Sauce was a B+. Pizza dough and crust was a C-. Topping A- in quality but D in application. I really wanted to like this place but for $40, there are several better options in area. Needs someone to help market their product better. Plus no pizza sign on North Side of building. Will not come back. Sorry. 2.5/5"

"This is a family owned restaurant along with their other location. I drive from a city with several pizza places for Augie's. Always excellent food."

"First time trying it and omg the sauce is the best sauce I’ve ever tried!!! Perfect thickness and literally the best cheese pizza we’ve ever had so far. Also, the stromboli was made to perfection! Will be ordering again and again !"

"Delicious pizza but the dining in experience isn’t ideal for a couple dining out. I would recommend this place for take out. There is constant ringing of the phone that you can hear since the place is so small. Also it can get super busy around 5 pm so be aware there may be a long wait time to be seated. Again the pizza is super delicious and I tried the regular and was very pleased."

"My first time at Augie's was approximately 20 years ago. Had ribs and pizza and didn't enjoy my meal at all. Tonight, March 2023 was my first time back since then. When we walked in there was a sign saying wait to be seated, a woman behind the desk said someone will be right with us. After several uncomfortable minutes standing at the sign, we were told to pick either of the booths up front. Several minutes later a waitress came by and gave us menus but did not even take a drink order. Several minutes after that she told us that their "technology" wouldn't link our order to our table if we could move to a different booth..... (There's probably 10 tables with six tables already occupied and eating, how hard would it be to really know where the order goes?) But we move to another booth anyway. After being there for probably 12 to 15 minutes not getting any attention or a drink order taken, we decide to leave and try a competitor across the street. Maybe we'll try again in 2043.... UPDATE 3-29-23 The owner reached out and apologized for the fiasco earlier in the month. My wife and I decided to give it another shot, and we are very happy we did! The service and food excellent! We ordered a pizza and a half rack of ribs dinner. Everything was perfectly cooked and tasty. I'm kind of a cole slaw connoisseur, and the Cole slaw was excellent! We will definitely be back to try some of their other offerings. Check it out, it's worth it!"