Angelina's Pizza 27095 Bagley Road, OH 44138

"I ordered two pizzas from Angelina's for my first time. One was a garlic butter based pizza with some veggies. It was tasty and perfectly cooked. I also ordered a take-n-bake red pizza with pepperoni. I think the sauce is a bit sweet for my taste and the pepperoni were nothing too special. But for both pizzas, the crust was the show stopper. Excellent crust with amazing flavor and texture will keep me coming back."

"I went to Angelinas for many years at the old location. It was always great pizza. I had not been to the new location until today. Trusting that it was always great pizza I never opened the box before I left. I got home and opened the box. To my surprise I was staring at a giant pile of mush!!!!!!! Nothing but soggy tomato sauce and cheese with very little toppings. The crust didn't seem to be cooked it was soggy as well! Basically for lack of a better term, When opening the box it looked like someone vomited up pizza in the box! I threw it in the woods off my deck. I hope the racoons don't get sick! NEVER AGAIN !!!!!!!!"

"Emma was a 13/10 top teir person/employee the driver was amazing too but Emma was the star of the show. She was nice caring and listened to all my dumb questions. The driver was amazing as well I didn’t get his name but he was sweet and double checked everything"

"This was our first time picking up pizza from the new location. We ordered 2 large and a small cheesy breadsticks. I’m not sure what happened but we still have one pizza left? Maybe it was a miracle of the multiplying pizza. Or, the pizzas were large enough and filling enough to fill us up? The cheese was my favorite part. The sauce is good too. The crust is very fresh too, but doesn’t seem to have any qualities to make it memorable. My one main question about this restaurant is- what are ‘fresh Italians’? Their logo advertises them as ‘the fresh Italians’. I find that a bit strange and confusing. Is their family known for their strong grooming? So they smell fresh and clean? Are they known to be young- so they’re the new kids on the block? It would make more sense if it just said, ‘fresh, Italian’. But when it says ‘Italians’, you’re clearly indicating the people behind the food. I’ll assume the owners are known for their strong grooming habits. Strong grooming habits and good pizza equals a pizza place worth trying. It won’t change your life, but it’s a good place to get pizza tonight."

"Last time I ordered (at least a year ago),the pizza was excellent and reasonably priced. This time, I’m very disappointed. The employee on the phone didn’t mention they’d moved from the Drug Mart plaza off Columbia Road, to the Shaker’s Plaza. I’d ordered a large pepperoni pizza. Expecting the usual high quality, I didn’t inspect it before leaving. When I got home, it was barely 1/4” thick, and the toppings were burned. The sauce used to taste homemade but now reminds me of Ragu. I won’t be back."