Sarah's Pizza

"We got delivery, said 45mins, here in 30. 10 gar/Parm wings and 3 subs...(1 steak), Terrific! Everything was hot, fresh, and however it happened, those Subs were Huge! Thank You Sarah's Pizza for a Great 'rest of' our Sunday. Hey folks, don't just post your bad experiences, cuz the good WAY outweigh the bad... Give Credit where credit is due, Sarah's is Brookvilles Best."

"I recently stumbled upon Sarah's Pizza in Brookville, and it's been a delightful discovery. Their pizza is not only delicious but also strikes the perfect balance of cheese and flavorful sauce. The thickness of the pizza dough is just right for me. The service here is exceptionally friendly, and they even offered me some deliciously spicy dried chili! Gonna be back there for some wings soon."

"LOVE THIS PLACE! I have been coming here for years and they never disappoint. The staff is so friendly and always get out orders right, even when we make special requests. A nice small- town feel inside. Thank you Sarah's!"

"Ordered delivery. From phone call to delivery was about 45 minutes. I was staying at the Holiday Inn and they brought the pizza to my room. Delivery guy was friendly and quick. Pizza itself was still piping hot. Looks like care was taken during the in route travel to my room as no damage was done to the box or pizza. I ordered a 4 topping supreme. Ingredients tasted fresh and the pizza was delicious. It has its own local flavor that is better than the average chain you see in every town. Would recommend over the chain places for sure."

"First time ordering from Sarah's. Order placed was for take out. For the most part the order was fine. Staff responded reasonably when I went in to pay for the order. Wait quoted over the phone on a Tuesday around 8:30 for a small pizza, basket of wedges, and two large subs was quoted at 25 minutes. Food was ready when I went to pick it up. Pricing is very reasonable. Pizza was ok. I liked the crispy crust. Wedges were probably my favorite of the order. I had a problem with the subs though. I ordered two BLT subs with no cheese. I received a B sub with mayo on the side. Bacon is not strips, it's pieces. So to be honest, it was like bacon bits on bread. This place seems to be a favorite among locals though, so they must be doing something right. However, I won't be returning because life is too short for bacon bits on bread."