Bayside Bakery & Cafe

"Mikayla and her team are so helpful and everything they make at their bakery is absolutely delicious! We tried everything from their lunch sandwiches to key lime pies and gluten free brownies and macaroons. Everything is always fresh and tastes soooo good. But the most incredible thing we have tried was our wedding cake that these guys made for us! Just wow! Vanilla cake with strawberry filling and some delicious cookies on a side. Our wedding guests wouldn’t stop talking about this cake! Hundred percent the best! Thank you for making our special day extra special!!!"

"Hey there! Today's weather was pretty gloomy, but it made me crave some delicious soup. Fortunately, I stumbled upon Bayside Bakery in PSJ and saw a sign that read "Soup of the Week: French Onion." Let me tell you, the soup was absolutely amazing! It had a truly restorative effect and was as comforting as a warm hug."

"I used Bayside Bakery for a custom cake order for my Mom’s 60th birthday! They did absolutely amazing and everyone complimented the delicious cake! I would highly recommend!!"

"Thanks to some spot on reviews, we could not have been happier with the birthday cake that we ordered while on vacation. Since we don’t frequent the area, we were a little hesitant to order a cake from an unknown bakery, but the service was excellent, the cake was delicious, and we were happy we read the reviews and took a chance with them. It was so good, I want to get some friends traveling there soon to pick another one up! Our cake had strawberry frosting between the layers, and a vanilla outside, and every drop got eaten! Thanks for the wonderful experience!"

"Had the honor of being surprised with my birthday cake from here. It was a beautiful cake that was made fresh. They really went out their way to make a special cake just for me. From my understanding they made it quickly and just for me. I love the beach so they hand crafting star fish and sand dollars to go on top. The cake was not too sweet even though it was all chocolate and it was light a fluffy. I must say this was the best cake I have ever had. Thank you for making my birthday amazing, I will use you for every cake going forward."