Dolce Mare

"We got got three different flavors (Peanut Butter, Tiramisu, and Cookie Dough)and they all basically tasted like vanilla. I've never had peanut butter ice cream not taste at least a little bit like PB. Very disappointing considering it cost $25 for three single scoops. Should have just went to Publix and got a quart of Tillamook. We will not be going back."

"Tried the strawberry shortcake and everything but the kitchen sink. Was amazing! My nephew loved the chocolate fudge! Wish I would have gone there earlier in my trip. Highly recommend"

"I would give this place a sixth star if I could. There's no way my photos will do it justice (I couldn't even wait until after we'd started eating), but we got strawberry, mint chip, and rocky road in one large ($10) and banana Nutella, cappuccino, and peanut butter in the other large. Every single flavor was delicious. I'd recommend them all. However, if you just want one refreshing flavor, I'd say to pick mint or strawberry, as you don't really need both in my opinion. The staff was also excellent. Everyone was kind and friendly to us, but the person scooping the gelato was the best. They were clearly knowledgeable on the flavors and recommended some of our favorites. If I could make one recommendation to this fantastic establishment, it would be to offer flights!! $15 for 6 half-scoops would be perfect. There were so many other flavors I wanted to try, but there was no option for a flight. If there was, I would have gotten the flight while my husband got a two-scoop. So, to reiterate, in case it's not clear, the flavors here are SO good that not offering flights is a crime. Please consider offering flights."

"First time on Marco Island and went to dinner at The Oyster Society which was Excellent. The Server Ivan Recommended Dolce Mare and told us to See Michelle Well, I met David her Husband and he was in the Middle of Making Scatch Chocolate Chip Cookies. Told me to come back in 14 minutes to try But First told Me try His Homemade Gelato. He had Me at Chocolate chip cookies, But Gelato is my weakness The Dark Chocolate and Cappachino was creamy and Delicious The Place smells amazing. From Homemade Gelato, Chocolate Chip Cookies, Chocolates and Cakes, everything is Fresh and Delicious. This Place is A Must visit when on Marco Island Highly Highly recommend Gregg"

"Best Gelato and sweet treats in the area. They have some relaxing chairs outside their store to sit and enjoy your desserts. There is a beautiful fountain in the middle of the courtyard to enjoy. The cookies were extremely large and fresh, also the dark chocolate sea salt caramel candy was yum yum. We would definitely come back her hear the next time we're visiting the area."