Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria

"3x I’ve ordered from this place and have done regular crust and gluten free. Toppings are scarce and expensive and pizza is dry. They can say in the comments it’s about picking it up on time but both times it didn’t make a difference. Edit: I dropped it down from 2 to 1 stars because the reply was sarcastic rather than asking questions to rectify, just like the others. People shouldn’t be in business if they can’t take constructive criticism and try to fix it."

"The absolute best pizza I’ve had in Sarasota hands-down. I’m from New York and I’ve been here for several years and until this place haven’t found a pizzeria that is actually good quality fresh pizza. The owner is the most friendly guy so personable the foods. Ingredients are super fresh, food is not overpriced, and the service is always top-notch"

"Normally their pizzas are pretty good. When ever company comes into town we always recommend their pizzas. However, today we ordered two mushroom & onion, (our go to pizza) for our guests. Unfortunately, they were not up to their usual quality. They were dry and could barely locate any onions or mushrooms. Hopefully this was a one time mistake because normally we really like their pizzas."

"Service is amazing and super kind. Food is pretty good. The pizza is delicious. Finally some good wings down here in Florida. And the salad is the best salad I’ve had at a pizza place here in Florida. Another great feature that we love is putting our order in advance online, so it’s ready to pick up after work on the way home. AND.. if you have a Marriott Bonvoy card… you score points. It’s literally a win win. And my boyfriend is finally happy with a place that gives you a normal amount of fries."

"Fresh Mozzarella is TRULY THE #1 PIZZA & ITALIAN FOOD RESTAURANT IN FLORIDA!!! When I moved to FL 23 years ago, I was disgusted to find that restaurants don't know how to cook. Dining in is an enjoyable treat. Rocco, the owner & chef, is a very talented & attentive chef. He multitasks waiting on customers while also preparing their meals. He is super pleasant & very courteous. The latest employees are just as helpful. I've gotten items like Two Slices of Pizza: 2 Pizza Slices with Extra Cheese, Ricotta & Tomatoes; Fettuccine with only butter & cheese on top - another yummy treat. The latest creation I've ordered was Extra Cheese, Ricotta & Eggplant Large 'BYO' Pizza. Delivery is available. But the best thing is to call the restaurant directly & tip well. Quit messing with 3rd party delivery."