Ruth K. Broad Bay Harbor K-8 Center 1155 93rd Street, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

"Dear School Administrator/Principal, My name is Flores Daniel, and I am writing to address a concerning incident that occurred this morning at the school drop-off. As a new parent to the area and with today being only my son's second week at the school, I had an unfortunate experience during drop-off. Upon arriving a bit early at 7:32am, my son expressed his shyness and confusion about where to go. Unfortunately, I did not see anyone available to guide the children besides the older gentleman assisting with getting the kids out of the car after the gates opened at 7:45am. When the gates opened, I walked towards the gate in search of guidance, only to be met with three instances of being screamed at, "Where do you think you're going!?!". I calmly explained that it was my first time and that I was unsure of where to go. The older gentleman, Alberto, responded rudely, stating that I couldn't go through there and turned his back to continue his duties. I waited until he turned back around and reiterated that I was new and seeking information for my son. In a disrespectful manner, Alberto pointed at me and said, "It's your first time, not his. He has a green polo for Ms. Jean's class, and he knows where to go," before turning away and laughing. While I understand the importance of ensuring our children's safety and enforcing protocols, I believe there is a more respectful and considerate approach to addressing parents, especially those who are new and seeking information. I asked again how we could enter the school as my son needed to use the restroom and was still unsure of where his class was. Alberto reluctantly stated that he would call someone to assist my son. We waited for approximately two minutes before I asked if he could use his radio to expedite the process becausehe didnt attempt to call for back up. Alberto said no someone will come soon. I wanted to bring this incident to your attention because I believe that fostering a welcoming and supportive environment for parents and students is crucial, particularly for those who are new to the school community. A positive and respectful interaction can greatly impact a parent's confidence in the school's ability to provide a safe and nurturing environment for their child. I kindly request that this incident be addressed with Alberto and that appropriate measures be taken to ensure that similar situations do not occur in the future. It is my hope that all parents, regardless of their familiarity with the school, feel comfortable reaching out for assistance and guidance. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I appreciate your time and feedback."

"As a student I attend Ruth K Broad most people say public schools are scary but this school is tottally different the teachers here are amazing the campus is a good balance between middle school and elementary. Some of the counselors are good there! Mrs. Nagler 5-8 grades. Some people there are not the best kids but that is like that at every school. I think this school is amazing definitely put your kid in this school. Thank you to Mrs. Etienne! Thank you Ruth K. Broad Bay Harbor K-8 Center"

"as a student that used to be in this school, i think it is ok, first of all, the summer camp was awful, we did not do anything exept sit in the cafetirea 75% of the day and the other 25% was going outside for 30 minutes. Second of all, most of the time the food is horrible. the nurse is useless and my forth grade spanish teacher was the rudest person i ever met. I hated going upstairs after p.e, there was a elevator but of course only the teachers get to use it. There were some good things bout this school like the fact that, my third grade was my favorite year yet. This school and bay harbor does bring some good memories"

"This school is great, I have my two kids there and we are delighted with their hard work and will to help the students! Mr. Saperstein, the principal, is a great role model for the kids and is always available to help! I am so grateful to be part of this community! Thank you Ruth K Broad."