Athenian Garden

"One of the best and most authentic Greek places around. The hummus was amazingly flavored and the gyro and steak sandwich were both 10/10. Must eat in St Pete!"

"We've driven by this place many times but never stopped. We finally decided to try it out. We had the hummus. It's a bit different than you might expect, but it was good. Probably a bit more authentic. I had the gyro, which was massive, but tasty. Pepsi restaurant unfortunately. Overall, it was pretty good, but a bit on the pricey side."

"This was a nice authentic Greek dining experience. The Greek salad was very delicious and plenty for 2. We also got the grouper avocado wrap. We split the traditional gyro sandwich. It was stuffed with flavorful meat. I had wished for more fresh ingredients on the sandwich like tomatoes and more tzatziki. They happily brought us more. It was filling!"

"I have a gluten allergy and when I called to ask some questions about the menu I was met with quite a negative experience. The employ initially was helpful asking the kitchen if there was gluten in a chicken dish. The answer was yes so I asked if there was any gluten in the chicken platter. She acted frustrated and asked me to call back in 20 minutes. I have a toddler and could not wait another 20 minutes to order dinner for our family. This was an incredibly frustrating experience being that many people have food allergies and the last thing I want to feel is that I’m an annoyance. We have ordered from this restaurant for years and this is a new allergy for me. So naturally I have questions as I learn to navigate it. A restaurant should either have food allergies posted on their site or equip their employees with the knowledge. And most important of all, they should hire people who are kind and respectful when met with questions from customers. Unfortunately we won’t be ordering from here any longer. I want to invest my money in local businesses who have customers’ best interest in mind."

"Absolutely amazing! I walked in and was greeted right away with a smile. After I was sat I was approached shortly after by Sarah who took my drink order. Everyone seemed very happy even though there wasn't anyone else inside the restaurant. I asked for suggestions and ended up going with my staple of a Gyro sandwich and french fries when I come to a new Greek restaurant. It was by far the best gyro I have ever had. The pita was warm and soft, the meat was juicy with a little crisp around the edges. The taziki sauce was obviously made in house and was perfect. The onions and tomatoes tasted fresh. The fries were all perfectly cooked. They were hot, crispy outside, and soft inside. I didn't need ketchup at all. I actually used them to lap up some of the taziki sauce that hit the plate. I highly recommend this place to anyone who loves gyros like I do."