Plaza Grill Restaurant, 5101 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050

"Stumbled upon this place when we wouldn't get a reservation anywhere else. The staff was amazing, they didn't have a kids menu but were willing to make chicken nuggets and noodles for them. Had the ribeye and tomahawk. Both were cooked to perfection and so good. Great little atmosphere."

"We were on vacation and decided on having dinner at this exceptional restaurant. As soon as we walked in the door, the host was so friendly and helpful in suggesting a martini and food and I am so glad that I asked him. He was 100% right! The waitress was very nice and prompt. This has been the best dining experience ever! Fresh and Delicious! Thank you"

"The dining experience at the Plaza Grill was nothing short of sublime. Nestled in the heart of the bustling Florida Keys, where tourists often struggle to find authentic cuisine, this hidden gem truly exceeded our expectations. The impeccable service elevated our evening to an extraordinary level, making us feel pampered and valued. What truly set this establishment apart was the genuine sense of savoriness that filled the air as we indulged in our meal. The food was a symphony of flavors, a delightful journey for our taste buds, leaving us utterly satisfied and gratified. But it wasn't just the food; it was the drinks that transported us to a state of bliss. The expertly crafted cocktails were a revelation, undoubtedly the best we've had in the Keys. Each sip was a harmonious blend of ingredients, enhancing our overall dining experience. What truly struck us was the warmth and hospitality of the staff. Everyone at the Plaza Grill exuded friendliness, making us feel like cherished guests rather than mere patrons. Their genuine smiles and attentive service added an extra layer of delight to our evening. In a place known for its touristy offerings, the Plaza Grill stands as a beacon of authenticity, offering not just a meal but an unforgettable experience. It's a place where culinary artistry meets exceptional service, leaving us with memories of a perfect evening in the Florida Keys"

"The Plaza Grill is a small restaurant open only for dinner in Marathon Key. This restaurant is unique. It is not a typical beach bar atmosphere. There is a good wine list. The options on the menu are superb and not as extensive as other restaurants that specialize in offering the typical fare found in the area. The number of tables are limited. Reservations are a good idea. The night we visited we sat at the bar and sampled several menu items along with glasses of Quilt Cabernet. The caesar salad was superb. The lettuce was fresh, the dressing was perfect. The coconut shrimp was perfect and had a delicious flavor. Our server, Alexandra was friendly and knowledgeable. For a good high end restaurant in Marathon Key that stands out from the rest, consider this option."

"Perhaps the best food and cocktails in Marathon. Service was exceptional, and the atmosphere was perfect for fine dining. This place is small, so I would recommend reservations for dinner. The steak was cooked perfectly, and the cocktails were well made and worth every penny. Bartender will do mocktails at a modest price, and they are just as good as the real thing. Give this place a try and support a local business."