My New Joint,

22658 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

"Ran out of chicken... can't even put an orange in a blue moon and no glass ... let me finish with the rest of the review then which I restrained because I didn't want to shame your restaurant... my sliders were pink inside yum pink chicken! And you ran out of a special at 530 at night learn to order. I stood at the door for 15 minutes where 4 different staff just looked at me and said nothing, finally a staff realized hey maybe it's my first time there??? The server is the only reason that saved the review to a 2! She was good. They didn't bring the basket of fries because they are very busy, so basically we had to cancel that part of the order. wow relax geez.... way to ruin my valentines!"

"Tonight, we were greeted by Ian. A long-time bartender. He hasn't seen us since last season. He remembers our name and drinks. He is fantastic and always makes us feel right at home. Nice to see him again! We started our meal with Blue Point Oysters! Fantastic! Hubby had the Wahoo and Tater Tots. It was on Catch if the day special! He said it was delicious! I had a Philly cheese quesadilla. Really good! I also had Cauliflower Au Gratin, delicious! The Wine and Alcolhol selection is subpurb! Music was pleasant , good sound! I would like to give a shot out to Lynn Bell. "The new Bar chairs are perfect! Thank You!!"

"The best bar in the Lower Keys with a more elevated Feel. Long time bartenders Ray, Ian, and Tanaka are staples and always make good drinks. Even when it's packed. Sit at the bar for best service. Servers can be slow. Specials are always good, Voodoo Shrimp are my go to but many excellent choices. Highly recommend."

"Great place. I prefer over Square Grouper on theain level due to typically no wait, and yet decent food although less variety than the Square. Nice appetizers, drinks, and limited main courses, but everything is quality a delicious. Never been disappointed. Great deserts, I recommend the Magic Bar. The cheese flight was generous compared to most. Always cheerful atmosphere and service."