Gatsby's Pizza

"Had a great experience today eating at Gatsby’s in Bonita. The owners Robin and Tim were amazingly friendly and run a super clean kitchen serving amazing pizza. Hubby had pepperoni and I had a veggie Gluten Free. Both outstanding. Highly recommend!!!"

"A hidden gem in Bonita, the owners Robynn and Tim are so passionate about what they do! It pours right into the food THEY prepare. Food is always consistent. Pizza is so clean and fresh. Not greasy! Great find especially with the OH connection! Best of luck to this venture!!"

"We have ordered take-out twice. Both times our pizza was superb! They do not skimp on the toppings, the spices they use really enhance the flavor and the thin crust is perfect. We will continue to have Gatsby's as our go-to pizza place!"

"10 stars they squeezed our entire soccer team! The staff was so accommodating and even offered to make pizzas i advance after a game! It was great experience for the team! Not many places are so accommodating we truly appreciate you communicating with us before the event and hopefully your ears are ok after all of that squealing!"

"When I walked in with my bf for our valentines date, we thought it was the cutest place ever, with tons of sports regalia and a sign supporting FGCU. Jackie and Sandy were so sweet, asking our names and checking in on us, asking how we were, if we needed anything and sharing a bit about their struggles, like a friend who has brain cancer… it felt like we became part of the family of the restaurant, just from having a few interactions with the staff and other customers. The food was just as good. We thought we would get a large pizza and save some for leftovers… the two of us ate the entire thing because it was so good. Definitely can’t recommend enough. I’ve never wanted to give a tip as big as we left here. Will definitely go again."