Mellow Mushroom Columbus

"I ordered a medium vegan veg out which was smaller than I expected for the cost. A medium pie in NYC is often just as expensive but seems bigger. The vegan cheese wasn't melted as well as it could have been and the taste of the slices was subpar. I also ordered a tempeh hoagie and it had no flavor and the cheese was completely unmelted and had no flavor. The service was terrible. The front of house staff taking the to go orders were not keeping up with orders. After making the order and being promised it would be ready in 45 minutes (an already lengthy wait). the order wasn't prepared for well over an hour and a half. I hope they do better with their non vegan pies because this was terrible and I was so excited because my previous Mellow Mushroom experiences were always amazing."

"Pizza was really good and cheese bread! Service was good, we just waited a long time for our food! Definitely would give it another try, I do recommend!"

"I love Mellow Mushroom. Always have been impressed with the service, quality of food, and whole experience. This Mellow Mushroom was the worst experience I’ve had at one. Our waitress was friendly, but not really available or quick especially with how many people were working. The salad had all brown lettuce the little bit that was in it. The one pizza took 32 minutes to come out and had been sitting for a bit because it was not hot. We asked for sides of ranch when we ordered initially, and again when we go our pizza, and again after we had all eaten a slice. Still got charged for it even though it came out after we had finished eating. The scenery is beautiful, incredible paintings. Such a shame the experience wasn’t. Would never recommend this one."

"Veggie pizza was delicious. Classic crust is light and delicious. Great wedge salad. Friendly staff. Would highly recommend Mellow Mushroom."

"The pizza is absolutely delicious!! Everything came to the table piping hot. You can certainly taste the freshness of the ingredients. We would get everything we ordered again. The staff does a tremendous job keeping the place clean. I’ve never seen tables get cleaned so fast once the customers leave. Our waitress was extremely kind and nice but the service was a little slower than we would have liked. Still….I will be coming back for and I highly recommend this spot for anyone who enjoys great pizza!"