Goodfellas Pizza & Wings 365 14th Street Northwest, Atlanta, GA 30318

"Out here on Atlanta on vacation. I review said this was the "best" pizza so I had to try. The pizza was very "soggy" no crunch. The taste was fine. I ordered a mushroom pizza and got about 8 3/4 mushrooms. That was very disappointing. Ordered jalapeno poppers and wow those things were burnt to crisp."

"First time here for lunch. Not too pricey. Service was direct. Nothing welcoming. I ordered all flats half lemon pepper wet and half bbq. There is an upcharge for all flats. I will never understand that. Wings were extremely flavorful. Only bad thing is wings were hard. Will I be back yes! I will try the Philly or pizza next!"

"I just picked up a to go order from Goodfellas. I ordered their special 14 inch two topping pizza, 2 liter drink and wings! To say the least I am very disappointed! I wanted a whole topped pepperoni and half topped italian sausage pizza. I guess it’s my fault that I didn’t look before I left, but it’s even on the ticket what I wanted…I could live with the mishap but this pizza is like one of the worst quality pizza’s I have ever had! Seriously! Wings and fries were blah as well! We’re in the A…lemon pepper should not get messed up like that! I tried to call to mention the mistake and no one answered so here I am on google reviews! Anyway today could’ve been an off day for them….however I won’t be trying them again! Also…parking is a bit of a mess…the shopping plaza has an active booter in the lot…eek!"

"I was actually surprised by the food. My husband and I got a spinach and feta calzone, Phillycheesesteak, and Jerk pizza. Food got done quickly but it wasn’t all that, very bland and lacked flavor. The jerk pizza barely had chicken on it and looked nothing like the online videos. Don’t believe those Instagram foodie videos. I basically got an all cheese pizza. The Phillycheesesteak, I’ve definitely had better. The fries were stale, it’s like we bit into a fry that’s been sitting in the fridge for two days. No seasoning on them. Literally drowned them in sauce and they still didn’t taste good. The spinach and feta calzone was okay, the cheese on the inside wasn’t all the way melted. The crust didn’t have any flavor and obviously it has spinach in it but every bite was literally a mouthful of spinach, the ingredients inside the calzone should’ve been distributed better. I wouldn’t come here again, literally a waste of $40."

"Man, I ordered wings and pizza on UberEats, both were delicious and still hot when arrived. Plus the Lemon Pepper is the real Atlanta one. Chef’s kiss day shift, cause my food was awesome! Other thing they could change is the blue cheese is kinda cheap, otherwise great!"