Plus 1 Pizza 10355 Pioneer Road, Byesville, OH 43723

"It's an average pizza shop. Nothing great. Descent pizza. I would recommend."

"Ordered a Supreme pizza for my grandfather and myself. It was hands down the best supreme pizza I've had in some time. I ordered ahead on the app for a later pickup and my pizza was still hot once I got it home. I ended up eating the rest of the pizza the next day!"

"This is my favorite pizza and I miss how good it used to be. Every couple months I try it again to see if maybe it’s just new people working but I think tonight was my last try. I normally spend close to $100 and I expect to get what I order. Tonight’s pizza just like the last few times is dry and very thin. I even try asking for extra sauce. Their wings are good but are soooooo expensive now. I would call and talk to someone but I already did that about 8 months ago and I don’t want them to think I’m just trying to get free food."

"Although the pizza was delicious and the service was average, there were two things i didn't like about it. They put the marinara sauce on top of my pizza causing it to be smashed down in 4 places!! i hate that! And they did not fully cut the pizza as I had to tear it apart!! I wanted to give 5 stars but they deserve only 4. I would eat there again since the pizza is delicious"

"I've been eating Plus One since I was a kid. It's always been good. Sometimes I feel like they skimp on the toppings whenever I use one of my rewards though. Every time I get a stromboli using a reward it only has meat and toppings in the two middle pieces and the sides are just bread. My biggest issue now is how expensive it has become. They used to offer decent paper coupons but now they aren't that great. The pick 2 for $5.99 kept gradually going up and now it's pick 2 for $9.25. When some of those items being offered for the deal is cheaper when buying it straight off the menu by itself. For example, a small cheesy bread is $7.95 on the menu, but for that specific deal it's $9.25. How does that make sense? I get it all places need to make money and have price increases but plus one has increased their prices more than other places. *8/12/22 - I just tried ordering again. Had a reward for a free small 3 topping pizza. It had hardly any banana peppers or ham on it. Every time I get something using a reward, they skimp on the toppings. I think they either changed suppliers or their recipe cause the crust was terrible. It was the worst I've ever had. I also got cheesy bread and it didn't look like it usually does and the crust was bad too. Before too long, I won't be reordering."