Mellow Mushroom Savannah

"Nice place with a slow service but after a slow start our waitress was really nice. The pizza is ok for an American restaurant, but the truth is it was better than expected."

"The party I was traveling with might disagree (they were complaining about the server and the amount of bread chips that came with the spinach and artichoke dip), but I thought the food was good and the server was on top of things as best she could be. However, it took A LONG TIME to get our food, and it was pretty empty. I’m not sure what was going on, but I don’t think we would have stopped in if we knew it would take so long. They were also obviously understaffed which is a bummer for those left. We got pizza, a burger, and a beer. It all was or looked good (I didn’t try the burger). I will say it was a bit pricey, but Savannah is a big tourist area, so it’s to be expected. As mentioned, for the little amount of food we got with a mostly empty restaurant, it took a long time to get the food. The vibe is super chill and fun. I love the decor. Booth and chairs were comfy enough. The tables we had were quite wobbly, but we MacGyver-ed it to make sure we didn’t spill our beer. The bathrooms are a bit tight - you need to do some dancing around the throne to fit. Actually just getting there you have to squeeze by a pole between tables or walk around someone’s chair while they eat to get to the doors , but it’s fine. I also thought the smell of the soap was pretty gross. Clean hands, though. You need ‘em, so, yeah. My kids loved that the floor had so many swoops and slopes and little steps. Just be aware if mini parkour isn’t your thing."

"I have been eating at Mellow Mushroom since I was a teenager in Atlanta. It’s always been my favorite pizza! However after moving to Savannah and ordering from the newly opened Mellow Mushroom here, we’ve had issues. We typically carry out so my review is solely about the pizza and people making it. We order from this place at least 2-3 Fridays per month. But the pizza has consistently had problems. We’ve tried calling and talking to management and staff and they apologize and say they’ll speak to the pizza cooks but nothing changes. The main issue is they use triple the amount of sauce on the pizza than any pizza I’ve ever eaten. So much sauce that the cheese and toppings slide right off the pizza upon picking up a slice to take a bite. Not only that, I order mine with light sauce and it’s got the sauce of a typical pizza. I don’t know why this is consistently an issue but it is. Also the crust that MM is famous for, being light, buttery, with Parmesan and scrumptious is not that way at this restaurant. The crust is usually brownish, crispy and missing all of the Parmesan and buttery delicious taste they are known for. They consistently ruin our pizzas and I’m fed up. So if you eat in the restaurant they might do everything well. However carry out is non consistent and the pizza is usually pretty bad."

"We ordered wings and a large pepperoni pizza Togo. The wings came out okay. The pizza however had no cheese on a few spots. I should’ve checked the pizza before leaving which is a mistake I won’t make again. We tried eating the parts with cheese and turns out the whole pizza has a bad after taste to it, like something wasn't cleaned well in the oven while cooking the pizza. The wings was chewy and felt like they weren’t fresh. My fiancé now sees why I value driving across to Pooler for the newer Mellow Mushroom. If you’re in Savannah, Godfathers. Update: we went back to the restaurant they allowed us a refund and apologized. I think they just had a bad day in kitchen. Extremely nice on service and attitude."

"Fun place with great food. Always love the dough here with a great sauce ratio. We ordered the House Special Pizza which is one of my favorites. Tons of toppings and a perfect amount of crust! Also, grabbed a small cheese pizza for my son and it was a wonderful pizza as well. My wife and I split a large Caesar salad as an app, it is plenty for two people and was dressed perfectly. The service was spot on and the decor was fun as usual. I love how each location has their own vibe. I’ve been to Mellow in many states and this has been one of the best, I still love them all. Enjoy!"