Chestnut Vale Feed Inc./ Hicksville Agway Company

"I cannot say enough good things about the people at Chestnut Vale, and how they went out of their way to deliver to the Science Museum of Long Island, exactly what we need, to make our community garden, a huge success in 2024"

"I get monthly outdoor bird seed supplies from here. They also sell chicken feed, horse feed, dog food, etc. The bird seed is higher quality and they sell larger quantity, priced accordingly. Their website does not list the amount of products they have in stock. It’s worth a look if you are seeking better quality feed and other products not readily available at pet stores or big box stores."

"Called on Sat to pick up hay. Was told they were open to 4PM. Drove in from Centerport in Suffolk County. They were closed. Sign on door says close @ 3PM. Don't there employees know that?"

"Do not get hay from them. The quality is horrible. Barely green. Mostly brown. And when I called they said “that’s the color”. I’ve gotten hay for years and oxbow is way better. I PAID $30 for delivery and they left it outside and DID NOT even call to let me know it was outside…had it rained ALLL of it would’ve been ruined. Sad part is…all they had to do was walk a few extra steps to leave it inside past the front door so it wouldn’t be exposed to the elements (they don’t bag it understandably). Waste of money. Now I have to pay extra to correct the issue myself. Don’t advertise quality hay on your website if it’s not. UPDATE: I called again and spoke to a supervisor who was empathetic and understanding. I was able to get a refund issued. If you order-I suggest picking out and picking up your own bale."

"I ended up going here for the first time ever because I recently bought a new rabbit so I needed hay. I was buying oxbow hay for my bunny because I heard it’s the best you could buy from the store, the only issue is my bunny was eating to much in a week (the bags are small) and wasting to much at the same time. I got fed up and searched up places I could buy hay and this one had the best reviews! I now see why their reviews are great. I bought a bale of Alfalfa hay for my baby rabbit and I’ve NEVER seen him go that crazy for hay. He literally stuffed his face in it and couldn’t get enough. I will most definitely be back in the future and I highly recommend them. They had good customer service as well. The bale was gigantic and will surely last me at least 5 months or more. Was only around $60ish after tax. It’s very large and heavy so be able to carry it or have accommodations."