Roslyn's Cellar

"If you have only one night to spend on Long Island, this is the place. The new My Fathers Place is THE best place to see a concert on LI. The room is intimate and the sound is fantastic. And the menu far surpasses any other music venue. It's Indian-influenced and everything I've tasted is great especially at the low price-point. Imagine, half a century ago, Michael Epstein opened up the original MFP and it stands as the finest music venue perhaps anywhere. Eppy definitely belongs in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame. Eppy, you've hit a home run"

"We love this place, clean friendly environment with spectacular entertainment."

"We had a nice night watching comedians last Friday, the food was good, the only thing that disappointed me, was the dessert portions, very small portions and the food presentation could improve a bit, the chairs were a bit uncomfortable very small. The waiters were friendly, nice staff."

"Great venue for the comedy of Fred Rubino who was fantastic last night (7/23). The 3 comics who opened for Fred were excellent. Good food and service. Definitely worth coming to a show here."

"I wish I could have left 0 stars to be quite honest with you. This was the worst hotel experience and I didn’t even get the leave Long Island for it. The staff here is so rude, I watched them curse out multiple guests for saying they didn’t like one of the dishes they ordered, which I can understand because the food was sub par, would’ve preferred to go to Outback honestly. My $18 Margarita tasted like orange juice. Also prices on the menu and bar were inconsistent considering at the table 2 drinks were $36 and when we went up the the bar they were $50. Additionally I went in to see a bands performance and about half way into their set the managers turned all the lights on on them and started heckling them from the back screaming not to play anymore songs, wasted and broke a wine glass. Needless to say there’s hundreds of other Niche hotels on Long Island and this one is a waste of money and a horrifying experience when you’re looking for some stress free time away."