Goodfella's

"I have been going to Goodfellas for about 6 years now, and I have great memories from this place. The pizza is spectacular, and has only improved. Not to mention, the calamari is just exquisite. Love this place, easy 5 stars."

"This place and Joe and Pats is the best on the island. The pizza is really good. The entrées are great. Try a specialty pizza. It’s fantastic in the brick oven. These guys been here a little while now"

"My husband ordered from Goodfellas and upon delivery we got the wrong pizza and the fried calamari was cold. The weird part was that the calamari wasn’t just cooled down it was literally cold as if someone just took it out from the fridge. Couldn’t chew through the calamari pieces either. We contacted the restaurant. They said that a manager would call us back. It’s been a while now and no one called us. Dinner was ruined for us. I few years back Goodfellas was our go to place. It’s probably been 6 months since we ordered from there last time..and now I remember why we stopped."

"We ordered a gluten free pizza. When my daughter started feeling sick after eating it, I looked at it carefully. There was mold on the crust, under the cheese! Whoever made it just put the cheese on and covered up the mold. That is just terrible. You should be ashamed. Never again."

"Excellent pizza, high quality, very kind server. Pizza has great value: delicious cheese, coal fired stove, you can pick your own toppings if you want. Choose your cheese style too (NYC or old school). Lots of choices, solid apps. The quality of the ingredients and finish were top rate - very fine pies, we’d come back for them. This is a hidden gem."