Tony's Brick Oven 1140 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305

"The food was absolutely delicious I HIGHLY recommend the “tour of Italy”. The young lady who checked me out and took the order was sweet and I didn’t feel rushed when trying to decide what to order. The man who was sitting at the table when I came in seemed like he was in a bit of a mood-rude a bit. That could be just how he acts as I don’t personally know him and this was my first time there. After I ordered and came back inside (I was waiting for my food to finish cooking) he was friendlier and talked to me in a more polite manner. I definitely recommend stopping by to get a true taste of Italian cuisine."

"Hands down the best pizza on the Island! Antipasto is to die for, absolutely perfect! I have yet to be disappointed with anything I have eaten here! It's my go-to comfort food. I could eat here every day of the week, and have a happy belly... Angelo and his team no how to keep you coming back for more!"

"So this place is nice to dine in and the owner is alright. My wife and I had a piece of pizza and I ordered an Italian Panini. My pizza was a thick crust vegetable and it was really good. My wife asked if the Margarita pizza sauce had a separate sauce but the owner played it off as it's normal to use the same sauce for everything as a standard, but we knew better.... The service was ok. The Panini was ok. I've been to Italy 4 times (if that matters). Not as good here but ok. I think you'll be delighted with the specialty pizzas here (except Margarita pizza if you're looking for authentic Italian (at least compared to Italy). Not an expert mind you, but my wife and I have been to Italy more than a few times and are always looking to experience Italy again wherever we go."

"Everything about this pizzeria is the best! Hands down best tasting sauce, crust, cheese, just everything ! If you want to try something really delicious, my favorite is always a pie with peppers and meatballs ! Angelo is very kind as well and I have never had an issue with this pizzeria. Worth every dime! This place is a MUST TRY AND MUST HAVE! Sincerely one of your favorite customers , Melanie :)"